English
(Kha) Or for whom indeterminate states will arise, for them will wholesome states arise? For Arahants endowed with the highest path, for them indeterminate states will arise, but for them wholesome states will not arise. For others, for them, indeterminate states will arise and wholesome states will arise. 58. (Ka) For whom unwholesome states will arise, for them will indeterminate states arise? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom indeterminate states will arise, for them will unwholesome states arise? For Arahants endowed with the highest path, for those who, immediately after this consciousness, will attain the highest path, for them indeterminate states will arise, but for them unwholesome states will not arise. For others, for them, indeterminate states will arise and unwholesome states will arise. (Kha) Direct Place 59. (Ka) Where wholesome states will arise, there will unwholesome states arise? Yes. (Kha) Or where unwholesome states will arise, there will wholesome st... Indeed, will they arise? Yes. (a) Where wholesome phenomena will arise, will indeterminate phenomena arise there? Yes. (b) Or where, moreover, indeterminate phenomena will arise, will wholesome phenomena arise there? In the non-percipient beings, indeterminate phenomena will arise there, but wholesome phenomena will not arise there. In the four-constituent realms, in the five-constituent realms, indeterminate phenomena will also arise there, and wholesome phenomena will also arise there. 60. (a) Where unwholesome phenomena will arise, will indeterminate phenomena arise there? Yes. (b) Or where, moreover, indeterminate phenomena will arise, will unwholesome phenomena arise there? In the non-percipient beings, indeterminate phenomena will arise there, but unwholesome phenomena will not arise there. In the four-constituent realms, in the five-constituent realms, indeterminate phenomena will also arise there, and unwholesome phenomena will also arise there. (c) Direct method: persons and places. 61. (a) For whom, where wholesome phenomena will arise, will unwholesome phenomena arise for him there? For those whose mind, immediately after, will attain the highest path, wholesome phenomena will arise for them there, but unwholesome phenomena will not arise for them there. For others in the four-constituent realms, in the five-constituent realms, wholesome phenomena will also arise for them there, and unwholesome phenomena will also arise there. (b) Or for whom, moreover, where unwholesome phenomena will arise, will wholesome phenomena arise for him there? Yes. (a) For whom, where wholesome phenomena will arise, will indeterminate phenomena arise for him there? Yes. (b) Or for whom, moreover, where indeterminate phenomena will arise, will wholesome phenomena arise for him there? For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for non-percipient beings, indeterminate phenomena will arise for them there, but wholesome phenomena will not arise for them there. i. For others, those with four constituents, those with five constituents, for them there unclassified states will arise, and wholesome states will arise. 62. (a) For whom, where, unwholesome states will arise, for them, there, unclassified states will arise? Yes, it is. (b) Or for whom, where, unclassified states will arise, for them, there, unwholesome states will arise? For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for whom, immediately after their mind, they will attain the highest path, for non-percipient beings, for them, there, unclassified states will arise, but for them, there, unwholesome states will not arise. For others, those with four constituents, those with five constituents, for them, there, unclassified states will arise, and unwholesome states will arise. (c) The opposite person. 63. (a) For whom wholesome states will not arise, for them unwholesome states will not arise? Yes, it is. (b) Or for whom unwholesome states will not arise, for them wholesome states will not arise? For whom, immediately after their mind, they will attain the highest path, for them unwholesome states will not arise, but for them wholesome states will not not arise. For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for them unwholesome states will not arise, and wholesome states will not arise. (a) For whom wholesome states will not arise, for them unclassified states will not arise? For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for them wholesome states will not arise, but for them unclassified states will not not arise. For those endowed with the final mind, for them wholesome states will not arise, and unclassified states will not arise. (b) Or for whom unclassified states will not arise, for them wholesome states will not arise? Yes, it is. 64. (a) For whom unwholesome states will not arise, for them unclassified states will not arise? For those endowed with the highest path, For those who are endowed with the final thought, for those Arahants, immediately after whose thought they will attain the highest path, for them unwholesome phenomena will not arise, but for them indeterminate phenomena will not not arise. For those endowed with the final thought, for them unwholesome phenomena will not arise, and indeterminate phenomena will not arise. (Kha) Or if for whom indeterminate phenomena will not arise, for them unwholesome phenomena will not arise? Yes. (Ṅa) The reverse (paccanīka) in terms of sphere (okāsa). 65. (Ka) Where wholesome phenomena will not arise, there unwholesome phenomena will not arise? Yes. (Kha) Or where unwholesome phenomena will not arise, there wholesome phenomena will not arise? Yes. (Ka) Where wholesome phenomena will not arise, there indeterminate phenomena will not arise? They will arise. (Kha) Or where indeterminate phenomena will not arise, there wholesome phenomena will not arise? There is not. 66. (Ka) Where unwholesome phenomena will not arise, there indeterminate phenomena will not arise? They will arise. (Kha) Or where indeterminate phenomena will not arise, there unwholesome phenomena will not arise? There is not. (Ca) The reverse (paccanīka) in terms of persons and spheres (puggalokāsā). 67. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome phenomena will not arise, for them, there unwholesome phenomena will not arise? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom, where unwholesome phenomena will not arise, for them, there wholesome phenomena will not arise? For those, immediately after whose thought they will attain the highest path, for them, there unwholesome phenomena will not arise, but for them, there wholesome phenomena will not not arise. For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for non-percipient beings, for them, there unwholesome phenomena will not arise, and wholesome phenomena will not arise. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome phenomena will not arise, for them, there indeterminate phenomena... Oh, will they not arise? For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for non-percipient beings, for them, there, wholesome states will not arise, but for them, there, indeterminate states will not arise. For those endowed with the last thought, for them, there, both wholesome states will not arise and indeterminate states will not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where indeterminate states will not arise, for him, there, will wholesome states not arise? Yes. 68. (Ka) For whom, where unwholesome states will not arise, for him, there, will indeterminate states not arise? For those endowed with the highest path, for Arahants, for those immediately after whose thought they will attain the highest path, for non-percipient beings, for them, there, unwholesome states will not arise, but for them, there, indeterminate states will not arise. For those endowed with the last thought, for them, there, both unwholesome states will not arise and indeterminate states will not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where indeterminate states will not arise, for him, there, will unwholesome states not arise? Yes. (4) Section on Present and Past (Ka) Affirmative individual 69. (Ka) For whom wholesome states arise, for him did unwholesome states arise? Yes. (Kha) Or again, for whom unwholesome states arose, for him do wholesome states arise? For all, at the moment of the dissolution of thought, at the moment of the arising of thought dissociated from wholesome states, for those who have attained cessation, for non-percipient beings, for them unwholesome states arose, but for them wholesome states do not arise. At the moment of the arising of wholesome states, for them both unwholesome states arose and wholesome states arise. (Ka) For whom wholesome states arise, for him did indeterminate states arise? Yes. (Kha) Or again, for whom indeterminate states arose, for him do wholesome states arise? For all, at the moment of the dissolution of thought, For a mind dissociated from wholesome, at the moment of arising, for those who have attained cessation, for non-percipient beings, for them, indeterminate phenomena arise, but for them, wholesome phenomena do not arise. At the moment of the arising of wholesome, for them, both indeterminate phenomena arise and wholesome phenomena arise. 70. (a) For whom unwholesome phenomena arise, for him do indeterminate phenomena arise? Yes. (b) Or again, for whom indeterminate phenomena arise, for him do unwholesome phenomena arise? For all, at the moment of the mind's dissolution, at the moment of the arising of a mind dissociated from unwholesome, for those who have attained cessation, for non-percipient beings, for them, indeterminate phenomena arise, but for them, unwholesome phenomena do not arise. At the moment of the arising of unwholesome, for them, both indeterminate phenomena arise and unwholesome phenomena arise. (b) Direct order, spatial context. 71. Where wholesome phenomena arise, there do unwholesome phenomena arise? ... (and so on) ...