English
Homage to the Blessed One, the Arahant, the Perfectly Self-Enlightened One In the Abhidhamma Piṭaka The Book of Pairs (Third Part) 9. The Pair of Dhammas 1. The Section on Designations (A) Outline 1. The Section on Word Analysis (A) Direct Order 1. (A) Wholesome, wholesome states? (B) Wholesome states, wholesome? (A) Unwholesome, unwholesome states? (B) Unwholesome states, unwholesome? (A) Undetermined, undetermined states? (B) Undetermined states, undetermined? (B) Reverse Order 2. (A) Not wholesome, not wholesome states? (B) Not wholesome states, not wholesome? (A) Not unwholesome, not unwholesome states? (B) Not unwholesome states, not unwholesome? (A) Not undetermined, not undetermined states? (B) Not undetermined states, not undetermined? 2. The Section on the Root Wheel of Word Analysis (A) Direct Order 3. (A) Wholesome, wholesome states? (B) States, unwholesome states? (A) Wholesome, wholesome states? (B) States, undetermined states? 4. (A) Unwholesome, unwholesome states? (B) States, wholesome states? (A) Unwholesome, unwholesome states? (B) States, undetermined states? 5. (A) Undetermined, undetermined states? (B) States, wholesome states? (A) Undetermined, undetermined states? (B) States, unwholesome states? (B) Reverse Order 6. (A) Not wholesome, not wholesome states? (B) Not states, not unwholesome states? (A) Not wholesome, not wholesome states? (B) Not states, not undetermined states? 7. (A) Not unwholesome, not unwholesome states? (B) Not states, not wholesome states? (A) Not unwholesome, not unwholesome states? (B) Not states, not undetermined states? 8. (A) Not undetermined, not undetermined states? (B) Not states, not wholesome states? (A) Not undetermined, not undetermined states? (B) Not states, not unwholesome states? 3. The Section on Pure States (A) Direct Order 9. (A) Wholesome states? (B) States, wholesome? (A) Unwholesome states? (B) States, unwholesome? (Ka) Undetermined phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena undetermined? (Kha) Reverse 10. (Ka) Not wholesome, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not wholesome? (Ka) Not unwholesome, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not unwholesome? (Ka) Not undetermined, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not undetermined? 4 Pure-Phenomena Root Cycle (Ka) Direct 11. (Ka) Wholesome phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena unwholesome? (Ka) Wholesome phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena undetermined? 12. (Ka) Unwholesome phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena wholesome? (Ka) Unwholesome phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena undetermined? 13. (Ka) Undetermined phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena wholesome? (Ka) Undetermined phenomena? (Kha) Phenomena unwholesome? (Kha) Reverse 14. (Ka) Not wholesome, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not unwholesome? (Ka) Not wholesome, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not undetermined? 15. (Ka) Not unwholesome, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not wholesome? (Ka) Not unwholesome, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not undetermined? 16. (Ka) Not undetermined, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not wholesome? (Ka) Not undetermined, not phenomena? (Kha) Not phenomena, not unwholesome? (Kha) Exposition 1. Word-Purification Section (Ka) Direct 17. (Ka) Wholesome, wholesome phenomena? Yes. (Kha) Wholesome phenomena, wholesome? Yes. (Ka) Unwholesome, unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (Kha) Unwholesome phenomena, unwholesome? Yes. (Ka) Undetermined, undetermined phenomena? Yes. (Kha) Undetermined phenomena, undetermined? Yes. (Kha) Reverse 18. (Ka) Not wholesome, not wholesome phenomena? Yes. (Kha) Not wholesome phenomena, not wholesome? Yes. (Ka) Not unwholesome, not unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (Kha) Not unwholesome phenomena, not unwholesome? Yes. (Ka) Not undetermined, not undetermined phenomena? Yes. (Kha) Not undetermined phenomena, not undetermined? Yes. 2. Word-Purification Root Cycle (Ka) Direct 19. (Ka) Wholesome, whole- are wholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are states unwholesome states? Unwholesome states are both states and unwholesome states. The remaining states are not unwholesome states. (Ka) Are wholesome states wholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are states indeterminate states? Indeterminate states are both states and indeterminate states. The remaining states are not indeterminate states. 20. (Ka) Are unwholesome states unwholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are states wholesome states? Wholesome states are both states and wholesome states. The remaining states are not wholesome states. (Ka) Are unwholesome states unwholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are states indeterminate states? Indeterminate states are both states and indeterminate states. The remaining states are not indeterminate states. 21. (Ka) Are indeterminate states indeterminate states? Yes. (Kha) Are states wholesome states? Wholesome states are both states and wholesome states. The remaining states are not wholesome states. (Ka) Are indeterminate states indeterminate states? Yes. (Kha) Are states unwholesome states? Unwholesome states are both states and unwholesome states. The remaining states are not unwholesome states. (Kha) The reverse 22. (Ka) Are not-wholesome states not-wholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are not-states not-unwholesome states? Yes. (Ka) Are not-wholesome states not-wholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are not-states not-indeterminate states? Yes. 23. (Ka) Are not-unwholesome states not-unwholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are not-states not-wholesome states? Yes. (Ka) Are not-unwholesome states not-unwholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are not-states not-indeterminate states? Yes. 24. (Ka) Are not-indeterminate states not-indeterminate states? Yes. (Kha) Are not-states not-wholesome states? Yes. (Ka) Are not-indeterminate states not-indeterminate states? Yes. (Kha) Are not-states not-unwholesome states? Yes. 3. Section on Pure States (Ka) Direct order 25. (Ka) Are there wholesome states? Yes. (Kha) Are states wholesome states? Wholesome Phenomena are phenomena and wholesome phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not wholesome phenomena. (A) Are they unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (B) Are phenomena unwholesome phenomena? Unwholesome phenomena are phenomena and unwholesome phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not unwholesome phenomena. (A) Are they indeterminate phenomena? Yes. (B) Are phenomena indeterminate phenomena? Indeterminate phenomena are phenomena and indeterminate phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not indeterminate phenomena. (B) The opposite 26. (A) Are they not wholesome, not phenomena? Excluding wholesome, the remaining phenomena are not wholesome, (but are) phenomena. Excluding wholesome and phenomena, the remaining are neither wholesome nor phenomena. (B) Are they not phenomena, not wholesome phenomena? Yes. (A) Are they not unwholesome, not phenomena? Excluding unwholesome, the remaining phenomena are not unwholesome, (but are) phenomena. Excluding unwholesome and phenomena, the remaining are neither unwholesome nor phenomena. (B) Are they not phenomena, not unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (A) Are they not indeterminate, not phenomena? Excluding indeterminate, the remaining phenomena are not indeterminate, (but are) phenomena. Excluding indeterminate and phenomena, the remaining are neither indeterminate nor phenomena. (B) Are they not phenomena, not indeterminate phenomena? Yes. 4. The Chapter on the Root Cycle of Pure Phenomena (A) The direct order 27. (A) Are they wholesome phenomena? Yes. (B) Are phenomena unwholesome phenomena? Unwholesome phenomena are phenomena and unwholesome phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not unwholesome phenomena. (A) Are they wholesome phenomena? Yes. (B) Are phenomena indeterminate phenomena? Indeterminate phenomena are phenomena and indeterminate phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not indeterminate phenomena. 28. (A) Are they unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (B) Are phenomena wholesome phenomena? Wholesome phenomena are phenomena and wholesome phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not wholesome phenomena. (A) Are they unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (B) Are phenomena indeterminate phenomena? Indeterminate phenomena are phenomena and indeterminate phenomena. The remaining phenomena are not Indeterminate phenomena. 29. (Ka) Are phenomena indeterminate? Yes. (Kha) Are phenomena wholesome phenomena? Wholesome phenomena are phenomena and wholesome phenomena. Remaining phenomena are not wholesome phenomena. (Ka) Are phenomena indeterminate? Yes. (Kha) Are phenomena unwholesome phenomena? Unwholesome phenomena are phenomena and unwholesome phenomena. Remaining phenomena are not unwholesome phenomena. (Kha) The contrary. 30. (Ka) Are they not wholesome, not phenomena? Excluding wholesome, the remaining phenomena are not wholesome, they are phenomena. Excluding wholesome and phenomena, the remaining are neither wholesome nor phenomena. (Kha) Are they not phenomena, not unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (Ka) Are they not wholesome, not phenomena? Excluding wholesome, the remaining phenomena are not wholesome, they are phenomena. Excluding wholesome and phenomena, the remaining are neither wholesome nor phenomena. (Kha) Are they not phenomena, not indeterminate phenomena? Yes. 31. (Ka) Are they not unwholesome, not phenomena? Excluding unwholesome, the remaining phenomena are not unwholesome, they are phenomena. Excluding unwholesome and phenomena, the remaining are neither unwholesome nor phenomena. (Kha) Are they not phenomena, not unwholesome phenomena? Yes. (Ka) Are they not unwholesome, not phenomena? Excluding unwholesome, the remaining phenomena are not unwholesome, they are phenomena. Excluding unwholesome and phenomena, the remaining are neither unwholesome nor phenomena. (Kha) Are they not phenomena, not indeterminate phenomena? Yes. 32. (Ka) Are they not indeterminate, not phenomena? Excluding indeterminate, the remaining phenomena are not indeterminate, they are phenomena.