English
Excluding indeterminate and phenomena, the remaining are neither indeterminate nor phenomena. (Kha) Are they not phenomena, not wholesome phenomena? Yes. (Ka) Are they not indeterminate, not phenomena? Excluding indeterminate, the remaining phenomena are not indeterminate, they are phenomena. Excluding indeterminate and phenomena, the remaining are neither indeterminate nor phenomena. (Kha) Are they not phenomena, not unwholesome phenomena? Yes. Section on the Exposition of Designations. 2. Section on Occurrence. 1. Section on Arising. (1) Section on the Present. O (Ka) Direct Person 33. (Ka) For whom wholesome states arise, for them unwholesome states arise? No. (Kha) Or for whom unwholesome states arise, for them wholesome states arise? No. (Ka) For whom wholesome states arise, for them indeterminate states arise? At the moment of the arising of wholesome states in the immaterial realms, for them wholesome states arise, but for them indeterminate states do not arise. At the moment of the arising of wholesome states in the five-constituent existence, for them wholesome states arise and indeterminate states arise. (Kha) Or for whom indeterminate states arise, for them wholesome states arise? At the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from wholesome states in the course of existence for all those being reborn, for them indeterminate states arise, but for them wholesome states do not arise. At the moment of the arising of wholesome states in the five-constituent existence, for them indeterminate states arise and wholesome states arise. 34. (Ka) For whom unwholesome states arise, for them indeterminate states arise? At the moment of the arising of unwholesome states in the immaterial realms, for them unwholesome states arise, but for them indeterminate states do not arise. At the moment of the arising of unwholesome states in the five-constituent existence, for them unwholesome states arise and indeterminate states arise. (Kha) Or for whom indeterminate states arise, for them unwholesome states arise? At the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from unwholesome states in the course of existence for all those being reborn, for them indeterminate states arise, but for them unwholesome states do not arise. At the moment of the arising of unwholesome states in the five-constituent existence, for them indeterminate states arise and unwholesome states arise. (Kha) Direct Place 35. (Ka) Where wholesome states arise, do unwholesome states arise there? Yes. (Kha) Or where unwholesome states arise, do wholesome states arise there? Yes. (Ka) Where wholesome states arise, do unclassified states arise there? Yes. (Kha) Or where unclassified states arise, do wholesome states arise there? In the non-percipient beings, unclassified states arise there, but wholesome states do not arise there. In the four-constituents, in the five-constituents, unclassified states arise there, and wholesome states arise there. 36. (Ka) Where unwholesome states arise, do unclassified states arise there? Yes. (Kha) Or where unclassified states arise, do unwholesome states arise there? In the non-percipient beings, unclassified states arise there, but unwholesome states do not arise there. In the four-constituents, in the five-constituents, unclassified states arise there, and unwholesome states arise there. (Ga) The direct (questions concerning) persons and planes. 37. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome states arise, do unwholesome states arise for them there? No. (Kha) Or for whom, where unwholesome states arise, do wholesome states arise for them there? No. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome states arise, do unclassified states arise for them there? In the formless realms, at the moment of the arising of wholesome states, wholesome states arise for them there, but unclassified states do not arise for them there. In the five-constituents, at the moment of the arising of wholesome states, wholesome states arise for them there, and unclassified states arise for them there. (Kha) Or for whom, where unclassified states arise, do wholesome states arise for them there? For all those arising, in the course of existence, at the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from wholesome states, unclassified states arise for them there, but wholesome states do not arise for them there. In the five-constituents, at the moment of the arising of wholesome states, unclassified states arise for them there, and wholesome states arise for them there. 38. (Ka) For whom, where... Now, when unwholesome states arise, do indeterminate states arise for him there? In the formless realms, at the moment of the arising of unwholesome states, unwholesome states arise for them there, but indeterminate states do not arise for them there. In the five-constituent realms, at the moment of the arising of unwholesome states, both unwholesome states arise for them there, and indeterminate states arise. (B) Or again, for whom, where indeterminate states arise, do unwholesome states arise for him there? For all who are reborn, in the course of existence, at the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from unwholesome states, indeterminate states arise for them there, but unwholesome states do not arise for them there. In the five-constituent realms, at the moment of the arising of unwholesome states, both indeterminate states arise for them there, and unwholesome states arise. (D) The opposing person. 39. (A) For whom wholesome states do not arise, do unwholesome states not arise for him? At the moment of the arising of unwholesome states, wholesome states do not arise for them, but unwholesome states do not fail to arise for them. For all, at the moment of the dissolution of consciousness, at the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from wholesome and unwholesome states, for those who have attained cessation, for non-percipient beings, both wholesome states do not arise for them, and unwholesome states do not arise. (B) Or again, for whom unwholesome states do not arise, do wholesome states not arise for him? At the moment of the arising of wholesome states, unwholesome states do not arise for them, but wholesome states do not fail to arise for them. For all, at the moment of the dissolution of consciousness, at the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from unwholesome and wholesome states, for those who have attained cessation, for non-percipient beings, both unwholesome states do not arise for them, and wholesome states do not arise. (A) For whom wholesome states do not arise, do indeterminate states not arise for him? For all who are reborn, in the course of existence, at the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from wholesome states, for them... Unwholesome phenomena do not arise, but for them, indeterminate phenomena do arise. For all those passing away, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, at the moment of arising of unwholesome phenomena in the immaterial realms, for them, both wholesome phenomena do not arise and indeterminate phenomena do not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom indeterminate phenomena do not arise, for them do wholesome phenomena not arise? At the moment of arising of wholesome phenomena in the immaterial realms, for them, indeterminate phenomena do not arise, but for them, wholesome phenomena do arise. For all those passing away, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, at the moment of arising of unwholesome phenomena in the immaterial realms, for them, both indeterminate phenomena do not arise and wholesome phenomena do not arise. 40. (Ka) For whom unwholesome phenomena do not arise, for them do indeterminate phenomena not arise? For all those being reborn, at the moment of arising of consciousness dissociated from unwholesome phenomena in the course of existence, for them, unwholesome phenomena do not arise, but for them, indeterminate phenomena do arise. For all those passing away, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, at the moment of arising of wholesome phenomena in the immaterial realms, for them, both unwholesome phenomena do not arise and indeterminate phenomena do not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom indeterminate phenomena do not arise, for them do unwholesome phenomena not arise? At the moment of arising of unwholesome phenomena in the immaterial realms, for them, indeterminate phenomena do not arise, but for them, unwholesome phenomena do arise. For all those passing away, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, at the moment of arising of wholesome phenomena in the immaterial realms, for them, both indeterminate phenomena do not arise and unwholesome phenomena do not arise. (Ṅa) Negative context 41. (Ka) Where wholesome phenomena do not arise, there do unwholesome phenomena not arise? Yes. (Kha) Or again, where unwholesome phenomena do not arise, there do wholesome phenomena not arise? Yes. (Ka) Where wholesome phenomena do not arise, there do indeterminate phenomena not arise? They arise. do not arise. (Kha) Or again, where undetermined phenomena do not arise, do wholesome phenomena not arise there? No. 42. (Ka) Where unwholesome phenomena do not arise, do undetermined phenomena not arise there? They arise. (Kha) Or again, where undetermined phenomena do not arise, do unwholesome phenomena not arise there? No. (Ca) The opposing person and place. 43. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome phenomena do not arise, do unwholesome phenomena not arise for them there? At the moment of the arising of unwholesome phenomena, for them there, wholesome phenomena do not arise, but for them there, unwholesome phenomena do arise. At the moment of the dissolution of consciousness for all, at the moment of the arising of consciousness dissociated from wholesome and unwholesome,