English
For those who have comprehended, at the moment of the breaking of craving, when the mind is disjoined from craving, for those who have attained cessation, for them the path truth arose, but for them the origin truth does not arise. For those who have comprehended, at the moment of the arising of craving, for them the path truth arose and the origin truth arises. (B) Forward spatial scope 60. Where the suffering truth arises… (all are similar to 'where'). (C) Forward personal-spatial scopes 61. (A) For whom, where the suffering truth arises, for them, there did the origin truth arise? For the Suddhāvāsa devas at the moment of the arising of the rebirth consciousness, for those being reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them, there the suffering truth arises, but for them, there the origin truth did not arise. For others being reborn in the four-constituent and five-constituent realms, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of life, for them, there the suffering truth arises and the origin truth arose. (B) Or, for whom, where the origin truth arose, for them, there does the suffering truth arise? For those passing away from the four-constituent and five-constituent realms, at the moment of the breaking of consciousness in the course of life, at the moment of the arising of the path and the fruit in the immaterial realms, for them, there the origin truth arose, but for them, there the suffering truth does not arise. For those being reborn in the four-constituent and five-constituent realms, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of life, for them, there the origin truth arose and the suffering truth arises. (A) For whom, where the suffering truth arises, for them, there did the path truth arise? For the Suddhāvāsa devas at the moment of the arising of the rebirth consciousness, for those who have not comprehended, being reborn, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of life, for those being reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them, there the suffering truth arises, but for them, there the path The truth arose. For those who have understood, at the time of rebirth, at the moment of the arising of the mind in the continuum, for them there, the truth of suffering arises and the truth of the path arose. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the truth of the path arose, for them there, does the truth of suffering arise? For those who have understood, at the time of passing away, at the moment of the dissolution of the mind in the continuum, in the immaterial realms, at the moment of the arising of the path and its fruit, for them there, the truth of the path arose, but for them there, the truth of suffering does not arise. For those who have understood, at the time of rebirth, at the moment of the arising of the mind in the continuum, for them there, the truth of the path arose and the truth of suffering arises. 62. (Ka) For whom, where the truth of origin arises, for them there, did the truth of the path arise? For those who have not understood, at the moment of the arising of craving, for them there, the truth of origin arises, but for them there, the truth of the path did not arise. For those who have understood, at the moment of the arising of craving, for them there, the truth of origin arises and the truth of the path arose. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the truth of the path arose, for them there, does the truth of origin arise? For those who have understood, at the moment of the dissolution of craving, while the mind is disjoined from craving, for them there, the truth of the path arose, but for them there, the truth of origin does not arise. For those who have understood, at the moment of the arising of craving, for them there, the truth of the path arose and the truth of origin arises. (Gha) The opposing person. 63. (Ka) For whom the truth of suffering does not arise, for them did the truth of origin not arise? It arose. (Kha) Or again, for whom the truth of origin did not arise, for them does the truth of suffering not arise? There is none. (Ka) For whom the truth of suffering does not arise, for them did the truth of the path not arise? For those who have understood, at the time of passing away, at the moment of the dissolution of the mind in the continuum, in the immaterial realms, at the moment of the arising of the path and its fruit, for them, the truth of suffering... The truth of suffering does not arise, and for them the truth of the path did not arise. For those who have not realized, while passing away, at the moment of the dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, for them the truth of suffering does not arise, and the truth of the path did not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom the truth of the path did not arise, for them does the truth of suffering not arise? For those who have not realized, while being reborn, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of existence, for them the truth of the path did not arise, but for them the truth of suffering does not arise. For those who have not realized, while passing away, at the moment of the dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, for them the truth of the path did not arise, and the truth of suffering does not arise. 64. (Ka) For whom the truth of origin does not arise, for them did the truth of the path not arise? For those who have realized, at the moment of the dissolution of craving, while consciousness is dissociated from craving, for those who have attained cessation, for them the truth of origin does not arise, but for them the truth of the path did not arise. For those who have not realized, at the moment of the dissolution of craving, while consciousness is dissociated from craving, for non-percipient beings, for them the truth of origin does not arise, and the truth of the path did not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom the truth of the path did not arise, for them does the truth of origin not arise? For those who have not realized, at the moment of the arising of craving, for them the truth of the path did not arise, but for them the truth of origin does not arise. For those who have not realized, at the moment of the dissolution of craving, while consciousness is dissociated from craving, for non-percipient beings, for them the truth of the path did not arise, and the truth of origin does not arise. (Ṅa) The reverse spatial context. 65. Where the truth of suffering does not arise... (Ca) The reverse case of persons and locations. 66. (Ka) For whom, where the truth of suffering does not arise, for them, there did the truth of origin not arise? For those passing away in the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, at the moment of the dissolution of consciousness in the course of existence, and in the immaterial realms, at the moment of the arising of the path and its fruit, for them, there the truth of suffering does not arise, but for them, there the truth of origin did not arise. For those in the Pure Abodes at the moment of dissolution of the rebirth-consciousness, for those departing from the non-percipient realm, for them there the truth of suffering does not arise and the truth of origin did not arise. (Question) Or for whom, or where the truth of origin did not arise, for them there does the truth of suffering not arise? For those in the Pure Abodes at the moment of arising of the rebirth-consciousness, for those being reborn into the non-percipient realm, for them there the truth of origin did not arise, but for them there the truth of suffering does not arise. For those in the Pure Abodes at the moment of dissolution of the rebirth-consciousness, for those departing from the non-percipient realm, for them there the truth of origin did not arise and the truth of suffering does not arise. (Question) For whom, or where the truth of suffering does not arise, for them there did the truth of the path not arise? For those who have realized (the truths) and are departing, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of life, in the immaterial realms, at the moment of arising of the path and the fruit, for them there the truth of suffering does not arise, but for them there the truth of the path did not arise. For those in the Pure Abodes at the moment of dissolution of the rebirth-consciousness, for those who have not realized (the truths) and are departing, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of life, for those departing from the non-percipient realm, for them there the truth of suffering does not arise and the truth of the path did not arise. (Question) Or for whom, or where the truth of the path did not arise, for them there does the truth of suffering not arise? For those in the Pure Abodes at the moment of arising of the rebirth-consciousness, for those who have not realized (the truths) and are being reborn, at the moment of arising of consciousness in the course of life, for those being reborn into the non-percipient realm, for them there the truth of the path did not arise, but for them there the truth of suffering does not arise. For those in the Pure Abodes at the moment of dissolution of the rebirth-consciousness, for those who have not realized (the truths) and are departing, at the moment of dissolution of consciousness in the course of life, for those departing from the non-percipient realm, for them there the truth of the path did not arise and the truth of suffering does not arise. 67. (Question) For whom, or where the truth of origin does not arise, for them there did the truth of the path not arise? For those who have realized (the truths) when craving is ceasing, when the mind is dissociated from craving, for them there the truth of origin does not arise, but for them there the truth of the path would not have arisen. For the Pure Abodes when the second thought is occurring, for those who have not yet comprehended,