English
at the moment of the arising of thought in the course of existence, at the moment of the dissolution of the path and its fruit in the formless realms, for them the truth of origination ceased, but for them the truth of suffering does not cease. For all who are passing away, at the moment of the dissolution of thought in the course of existence, for them the truth of origination ceased, and the truth of suffering ceases. (A) For whom For whom the truth of suffering ceases, for them did the truth of the path cease? For those not yet realized, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of passing away, for them the truth of suffering ceases, but for them the truth of the path did not cease. For those who have realized, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of passing away, for them the truth of suffering ceases and the truth of the path did cease. (B) Or for whom the truth of the path did cease, for them does the truth of suffering cease? For those who have realized, at the moment of the mind's arising in the course of being reborn, in the formless realms, at the moment of the path's and fruit's dissolution, for them the truth of the path did cease, but for them the truth of suffering does not cease. For those who have realized, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of passing away, for them the truth of the path did cease and the truth of suffering ceases. 107. (A) For whom the truth of origin ceases, for them did the truth of the path cease? For those not yet realized, at the moment of craving's dissolution, for them the truth of origin ceases, but for them the truth of the path did not cease. For those who have realized, at the moment of craving's dissolution, for them the truth of origin ceases and the truth of the path did cease. (B) Or for whom the truth of the path did cease, for them does the truth of origin cease? For those who have realized, at the moment of craving's arising, when the mind is dissociated from craving, for those who have attained cessation, for them the truth of the path did cease, but for them the truth of origin does not cease. For those who have realized, at the moment of craving's dissolution, for them the truth of the path did cease and the truth of origin ceases. (B) Forward order, spatial. 108. Where the truth of suffering ceases… (and so on)… (C) Forward order, personal and spatial. 109. (A) For whom, where the truth of suffering ceases, for them, there did the truth of origin cease? For the Pure Abodes, at the moment of the rebirth-consciousness's dissolution, for the non-percipient beings passing away, for them, there the truth of suffering ceases, but for them… there the truth of origin ceased. For others, those passing away from four-constituent and five-constituent existences, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of existence, for them there the truth of suffering ceases and the truth of origin ceased. (Q) Or for whom, or where, the truth of origin ceased, for them there does the truth of suffering cease? For those arising in four-constituent and five-constituent existences, at the moment of the mind's arising in the course of existence, and in the formless realms, at the moment of the path's and fruit's dissolution, for them there the truth of origin ceased, but for them there the truth of suffering does not cease. For those passing away from four-constituent and five-constituent existences, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of existence, for them there the truth of origin ceased and the truth of suffering ceases. (Q) For whom, or where, the truth of suffering ceases, for them there did the truth of the path cease? For those in the Pure Abodes, at the moment of the rebirth-consciousness's dissolution, for those who have not realized, when passing away, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of existence, for non-percipient beings, when passing away, for them there the truth of suffering ceases, but for them there the truth of the path did not cease. For those who have realized, when passing away, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of existence, for them there the truth of suffering ceases and the truth of the path ceased. (Q) Or for whom, or where, the truth of the path ceased, for them there does the truth of suffering cease? For those who have realized, when arising, at the moment of the mind's arising in the course of existence, and in the formless realms, at the moment of the path's and fruit's dissolution, for them there the truth of the path ceased, but for them there the truth of suffering does not cease. For those who have realized, when passing away, at the moment of the mind's dissolution in the course of existence, for them there the truth of the path ceased and the truth of suffering ceases. 110. (Q) For whom, or where, the truth of origin ceases, for them there did the truth of the path cease? For those who have not realized, at the moment of craving's dissolution, for them there the truth of origin ceases. and not for them there the truth of the path ceased. For those who have comprehended, at the moment of the cessation of craving, for them there the truth of origin ceases and the truth of the path ceased. (Kha) Or again for whom, where the truth of the path ceased, for him there does the truth of origin cease? For those who have comprehended, at the moment of the arising of craving, when the mind is dissociated from craving, for them there the truth of the path ceased, and not for them there the truth of origin ceases. For those who have comprehended, at the moment of the cessation of craving, for them there the truth of the path ceased and the truth of origin ceases. (Gha) The opposing individual. 111. (Ka) For whom the truth of suffering does not cease, for him the truth of origin did not cease? It ceased. (Kha) Or again for whom the truth of origin did not cease, for him the truth of suffering does not cease? There is none. (Ka) For whom the truth of suffering does not cease, for him the truth of the path did not cease? For those who have comprehended, when reappearing, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of existence, in the formless realms, at the moment of the cessation of the path and the fruit, for them the truth of suffering does not cease, and not for them the truth of the path did not cease. For those who have not comprehended, when reappearing, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of existence, for them the truth of suffering does not cease and the truth of the path did not cease. (Kha) Or again for whom the truth of the path did not cease, for him the truth of suffering does not cease? For those who have not comprehended, when passing away, at the moment of the cessation of consciousness in the course of existence, for them the truth of the path did not cease, and not for them the truth of suffering does not cease. For those who have not comprehended, when reappearing, at the moment of the arising of consciousness in the course of existence, for them the truth of the path did not cease and the truth of suffering does not cease. 112. (Ka) For whom the truth of origin does not cease, for him the truth of the path did not cease? For those who have comprehended, at the moment of the arising of craving, with a mind dissociated from craving In this case, for those who have attained cessation, the truth of origin does not cease for them, but the truth of the path did not cease for them. For those who have not yet comprehended, at the moment of craving's arising, while a mind dissociated from craving is occurring, for non-percipient beings, the truth of origin does not cease for them, and the truth of the path did not cease for them. (Kha) Or again, for whom the truth of the path did not cease, for him, does the truth of origin not cease? For those who have not yet comprehended, at the moment of craving's dissolution, the truth of the path did not cease for them, but the truth of origin does not cease for them. For those who have not yet comprehended, at the moment of craving's arising, while a mind dissociated from craving is occurring, for non-percipient beings, the truth of the path did not cease for them, and the truth of origin does not cease for them. (Nga) The contrary case. 113. Where the truth of suffering does not cease...etc.... (Ca) The contrary scope for persons. 114. (Ka) For whom, where the truth of suffering does not cease, for him, there, did the truth of origin not cease? For those being reborn in the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, at the moment of the arising of mind in the course of existence, and at the moment of the dissolution of the path and its fruit in the formless realms, for them, there, the truth of suffering does not cease, but for them, there, the truth of origin did not cease. For those in the Pure Abodes, at the moment of the arising of the rebirth-linking consciousness, for those being reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them, there, the truth of suffering does not cease, and the truth of origin did not cease. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the truth of origin did not cease, for him, there, does the truth of suffering not cease? For those in the Pure Abodes, at the moment of the dissolution of the rebirth-linking consciousness, for those passing away from the non-percipient realm, for them, there, the truth of origin did not cease, but for them, there, the truth of suffering does not cease. For those in the Pure Abodes, at the moment of the arising of the rebirth-linking consciousness, for those being reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them, there, the truth of origin did not cease, and the truth of suffering does not cease. (Ka) For whom, where suffering... whose suffering truth does not cease there, did their path truth not cease there? For those who have comprehended,