English
129. (Ka) For whom the aggregate of feeling does not cease, for him the aggregate of perception did not cease? It ceased. (Kha) Or for whom the aggregate of perception did not cease, for him the aggregate of feeling does not cease? There is none. (Ṅa) Counter-place 130. Where the aggregate of form does not cease (the "where" should be completed). (Ca) Counter-individuals and places 131. (Ka) For whom, where the aggregate of form does not cease, for him, there the aggregate of feeling did not cease? For those reborn into the five-constituent existence, and for those in the formless realms, for them there the aggregate of form does not cease, but for them there the aggregate of feeling did not cease. For those reborn into the Pure Abodes, and for those reborn into the non-percipient realm, for them there the aggregate of form also does not cease and the aggregate of feeling also did not cease. (Kha) Or for whom, where the aggregate of feeling did not cease, for him, there the aggregate of form does not cease? For those attaining final Nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, and for those passing away from the non-percipient realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling did not cease, but for them there the aggregate of form does not cease. For those reborn into the Pure Abodes, and for those reborn into the non-percipient realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling also did not cease and the aggregate of form also does not cease. 132. (Ka) For whom, where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, for him, there the aggregate of perception did not cease? For those reborn into the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not cease and for them there, the perception aggregate did not cease. For those non-percipient beings reappearing in the Pure Abodes, for them there, the feeling aggregate does not cease, and the perception aggregate did not cease. (b) Or again, for whom, where the perception aggregate did not cease, for him there, does the feeling aggregate not cease? For those attaining final Nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there, the perception aggregate did not cease, but for them there, the feeling aggregate does not cease. For those non-percipient beings reappearing in the Pure Abodes, for them there, the perception aggregate did not cease, and the feeling aggregate does not cease. (5) Section on Present and Future (a) Affirmative Person 133. (a) For whom the form aggregate ceases, for him will the feeling aggregate cease? For those attaining final Nibbana in the five-constituent existence, for them the form aggregate ceases, but for them the feeling aggregate will not cease. For others, for those passing away from the five-constituent existence, for those passing away from non-percipient beings, for them the form aggregate ceases, and the feeling aggregate will cease. (b) Or again, for whom the feeling aggregate will cease, for him does the form aggregate cease? For all who are reappearing, for those passing away from the formless existence, for them the feeling aggregate will cease, but for them the form aggregate does not cease. For those passing away from the five-constituent existence, for those passing away from non-percipient beings, for them the feeling aggregate will cease, and the form aggregate ceases. 134. (a) For whom the feeling aggregate ceases, for him will the perception aggregate cease? For those attaining final Nibbana, for them the feeling aggregate ceases, but for them the perception aggregate will not cease. For others, for those passing away from the four-constituent existence, from the five-constituent existence, for them the feeling aggregate ceases, and the perception aggregate will cease. (b) Or again, for whom the perception aggregate will cease, for him does the feeling aggregate cease? For all who are reappearing, for those passing away from non-percipient beings, for them the s the perception aggregate will cease, but their feeling aggregate does not cease. For those who are passing away from the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, their perception aggregate will cease and their feeling aggregate ceases. (Kha) Direct Case (Anuloma-okāsa) 135. Where the form aggregate ceases… (etc.) (Ga) Direct Person-Case (Anuloma-puggalokāsa) 136. (Ka) For whom, where the form aggregate ceases, will their feeling aggregate cease there? For those attaining final Nibbāna in the five-constituent existence, and for those passing away from the non-percipient beings, their form aggregate ceases there, but their feeling aggregate will not cease there. For others who are passing away from the five-constituent existence, their form aggregate ceases there and their feeling aggregate will cease there. (Kha) Or for whom, where the feeling aggregate will cease, does their form aggregate cease there? For those being reborn in the five-constituent existence, and for those in the formless realms, their feeling aggregate will cease there, but their form aggregate does not cease there. For those passing away from the five-constituent existence, their feeling aggregate will cease there and their form aggregate ceases there. 137. (Ka) For whom, where the feeling aggregate ceases, will their perception aggregate cease there? For those attaining final Nibbāna, their feeling aggregate ceases there, but their perception aggregate will not cease there. For others who are passing away from the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, their feeling aggregate ceases there and their perception aggregate will cease there. (Kha) Or for whom, where the perception aggregate will cease, does their feeling aggregate cease there? For those being reborn in the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, their perception aggregate will cease there, but their feeling aggregate does not cease there. For those passing away from the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, their perception aggregate will cease there and their feeling aggregate ceases there. (Gha) Reverse Person (Paccanīka-puggala) 138. (Ka) For whom, where the r For whom the form aggregate does not cease, for him will the feeling aggregate not cease? For all who are arising, for those passing away from the formless realms, for them the form aggregate does not cease, but for them the feeling aggregate will not cease. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the formless realms, for them the form aggregate also does not cease, and the feeling aggregate also will not cease. (B) Or for whom the feeling aggregate will not cease, for him does the form aggregate not cease? For those attaining final Nibbāna in the five-constituent realms, for them the feeling aggregate will not cease, but for them the form aggregate does not cease. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the formless realms, for them the feeling aggregate also will not cease, and the form aggregate also does not cease. 139. (A) For whom the feeling aggregate does not cease, for him will the perception aggregate not cease? It will cease. (B) Or for whom the perception aggregate will not cease, for him does the feeling aggregate not cease? It does cease. (C) The reverse case. 140. Where the form aggregate does not cease... (etc.) (D) The reverse case for individuals and places. 141. (A) For whom, where the form aggregate does not cease, for him there will the feeling aggregate not cease? For those arising in the five-constituent realms, for those in the formless realms, for them there the form aggregate does not cease, but for them there the feeling aggregate will not cease. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the formless realms, for those arising in the non-percipient realm, for them there the form aggregate also does not cease, and the feeling aggregate also will not cease. (B) Or for whom, where the feeling aggregate will not cease, for him there does the form aggregate not cease? For those attaining final Nibbāna in the five-constituent realms, for those passing away from the non-percipient realm, for them there the feeling aggregate will not cease, but for them there the form aggregate does not cease. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the formless realms, for those arising in the non-percipient realm, for them there the feeling aggregate also will not cease, and the form aggregate also does not cease. ati. 142. (a) For whom, where, the aggregate of feeling does not cease, for them, there, will the aggregate of perception not cease? For those who are arising in the four-constituent and five-constituent existences, for them, there, the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but for them, there, the aggregate of perception will not cease. For non-percipient beings, for them, there, the aggregate of feeling does not cease, and the aggregate of perception will not cease. (b) Or for whom, where, the aggregate of perception will not cease, for them, there, does the aggregate of feeling not cease? For those who are attaining final Nibbāna, for them, there, the aggregate of perception will not cease, but for them, there, the aggregate of feeling does not cease. For non-percipient beings, for them, there, the aggregate of perception will not cease, and the aggregate of feeling does not cease. (6) Past and Future Section (a) Direct Person 143. (a) For whom the aggregate of form ceased, for them will the aggregate of feeling cease? For those who are attaining final Nibbāna, for them the aggregate of form ceased, but for them the aggregate of feeling will not cease. For others, for them the aggregate of form ceased, and the aggregate of feeling will cease. (b) Or for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, for them did the aggregate of form cease? Yes. 144. (a) For whom the aggregate of feeling ceased, for them will the aggregate of perception cease?