English
but for them there the perception aggregate does cease. For the non-percipient beings, for them there the feeling aggregate does not arise, and the perception aggregate does not cease. (B) Or for whom, or where, the perception aggregate does not cease, for them there does the feeling aggregate not arise? For those arising in the four-constituent existence, in the five-constituent existence, for them there the perception aggregate does not cease, but for them there the feeling aggregate does arise. For the non-percipient beings, for them there the perception aggregate does not cease, and the feeling aggregate does not arise. (2) Past Section (A) Direct Person 165. (A) For whom the form aggregate arose, for them did the feeling aggregate cease? Yes. (B) Or for whom the feeling aggregate ceased, for them did the form aggregate arise? Yes. 166. (A) For whom the feeling aggregate arose, for them did the perception aggregate cease? Yes. (B) Or for whom the perception aggregate ceased, for them did the feeling aggregate arise? Yes. (B) Direct Place 167. Where the form aggregate arose... (etc.). (C) Direct Person Non-spatial 168. (Ka) For whom, where, the form aggregate arose, for him, there, did the feeling aggregate cease? For the non-percipient beings, there, the form aggregate arose, but for them, there, the feeling aggregate did not cease. For the five-constituent beings, there, both the form aggregate arose and the feeling aggregate ceased. (Kha) Or for whom, where, the feeling aggregate ceased, for him, there, did the form aggregate arise? For the formless beings, there, the feeling aggregate ceased, but for them, there, the form aggregate did not arise. For the five-constituent beings, there, both the feeling aggregate ceased and the form aggregate arose. 169. (Ka) For whom, where, the feeling aggregate arose, for him, there, did the perception aggregate cease? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom, where, the perception aggregate ceased, for him, there, did the feeling aggregate arise? Yes. (Gha) Opposite Individual 170. (Ka) For whom the form aggregate did not arise, for him did the feeling aggregate not cease? There is none. (Kha) Or for whom the feeling aggregate did not cease, for him did the form aggregate not arise? There is none. 171. (Ka) For whom the feeling aggregate did not arise, for him did the perception aggregate not cease? There is none. (Kha) Or for whom the perception aggregate did not cease, for him did the feeling aggregate not arise? There is none. (Ṅa) Opposite Space 172. Where the form aggregate did not arise... (etc.) (Ca) Opposite Individuals and Spaces 173. (Ka) For whom, where, the form aggregate did not arise, for him, there, did the feeling aggregate not cease? For the formless beings, there, the form aggregate did not arise, but for them, there, the feeling aggregate ceased. For the Pure Abodes beings, there, both the form aggregate did not arise and the feeling aggregate did not cease. (Kha) Or for whom, where, the feeling aggrega... the feeling aggregate did not cease for them there, and did the form aggregate not arise? For the non-percipient beings, for them there, the feeling aggregate did not cease, but for them there, the form aggregate did not arise. For the Pure Abode beings, for them there, the feeling aggregate did not cease, and the form aggregate did not arise. 174. (A) For whom, where, the feeling aggregate did not arise, for them there, did the perception aggregate not cease? Yes. (B) Or for whom, where, the perception aggregate did not cease, for them there, did the feeling aggregate not arise? Yes. (3) The Future Section (A) Direct Person 175. (A) For whom the form aggregate will arise, for them will the feeling aggregate cease? Yes. (B) Or for whom the feeling aggregate will cease, for them will the form aggregate arise? For those who are last-existents, arising, and those who, having arisen in the formless realm, will attain final Nibbāna, for them the feeling aggregate will cease, but for them the form aggregate will not arise. For the others, for them, the feeling aggregate will cease, and the form aggregate will arise. 176. (A) For whom the feeling aggregate will arise, for them will the perception aggregate cease? Yes. (B) Or for whom the perception aggregate will cease, for them will the feeling aggregate arise? For those who are last-existents, arising, for them the perception aggregate will cease, but for them the feeling aggregate will not arise. For the others, for them, the perception aggregate will cease, and the feeling aggregate will arise. (B) Direct Place 177. Where the form aggregate will arise…and so on…. (C) Direct Person and Place 178. (A) For whom, where, the form aggregate will arise, for them there, will the feeling aggregate cease? For the non-percipient beings, for them there, the form aggregate will arise, but for them there, the feeling aggregate will not cease. For the five-constituent beings, for them there, the form aggregate will arise, and the feeling aggregate will cease. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the feeling aggregate will cease, will the form aggregate arise there for them? For those who are last-existents, re-arising in the five-constituent realm, and for those in the formless realm, for them the feeling aggregate will cease there, but for them the form aggregate will not arise there. For others in the five-constituent realm, for them the feeling aggregate will cease there, and the form aggregate will arise there. 179. (Ka) For whom, or where, the feeling aggregate will arise, will the perception aggregate cease there for them? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the perception aggregate will cease, will the feeling aggregate arise there for them? For those who are last-existents, re-arising, for them the perception aggregate will cease there, but for them the feeling aggregate will not arise there. For others in the four-constituent realm, and in the five-constituent realm, for them the perception aggregate will cease there, and the feeling aggregate will arise there. (Gha) The opposite person. 180. (Ka) For whom the form aggregate will not arise, will the feeling aggregate not cease for them? For those who are last-existents, re-arising, and those who, having re-arisen in the formless realm, will attain final Nibbāna, for them the form aggregate will not arise, but for them the feeling aggregate will not not cease. For those attaining final Nibbāna, for them the form aggregate will not arise, and the feeling aggregate will not cease. (Kha) Or for whom the feeling aggregate will not cease, will the form aggregate not arise for them? Yes. 181. (Ka) For whom the feeling aggregate will not arise, will the perception aggregate not cease for them? For those who are last-existents, re-arising, for them the feeling aggregate will not arise, but for them the perception aggregate will not not cease. For those attaining final Nibbāna, for them the feeling aggregate will not arise, and the perception aggregate will not cease. (Kha) For whom Or again, will the perception aggregate not cease, and then the feeling aggregate not arise? Yes. (Ña) Negative Locality 182. Where the form aggregate will not arise...etc.... (Ca) Negative Person-Localities 183. (a) For whom, where the form aggregate will not arise, for him, there will the feeling aggregate not cease? For those in their last existence who are arising in the five-constituent existence, and for those in the formless realms, for them, there the form aggregate will not arise, but for them, there the feeling aggregate will cease. For those who are attaining final Nibbāna, for them, there the form aggregate will not arise and the feeling aggregate will not cease. (b) Or again, for whom, where the feeling aggregate will not cease, for him, there will the form aggregate not arise? For the non-percipient beings, for them, there the feeling aggregate will not cease, but for them, there the form aggregate will arise. For those who are attaining final Nibbāna, for them, there the feeling aggregate will not cease and the form aggregate will not arise. 184. (a) For whom, where the feeling aggregate will not arise, for him, there will the perception aggregate not cease? For those in their last existence who are arising, for them, there the feeling aggregate will not arise, but for them, there the perception aggregate will cease. For those who are attaining final Nibbāna, and for the non-percipient beings, for them, there the feeling aggregate will not arise and the perception aggregate will not cease. (b) Or again, for whom, where the perception aggregate will not cease, for him, there will the feeling aggregate not arise? Yes. (4) Present-Past Section (a) Affirmative Person 185. (a) For whom the form aggregate arises, for him did the feeling aggregate cease? Yes. (b) Or again, for whom the feeling aggregate ceased, for him does the form aggregate arise? For all who are passing away, and for those arising in the formless realms, for them the feeling aggregate ceased, but for them the form aggregate does not a... is reborn. For those being reborn in the five-constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them the feeling aggregate ceased and the form aggregate arises… (etc.)…. (Just as in the arising section, the present and past were analyzed, so should it be analyzed here.) (5) Present and Future Section (a) Affirmative Individual 186. (a) For whom the form aggregate arises, for him will the feeling aggregate cease? Yes. (b) Or for whom will the feeling aggregate cease, for him does the form aggregate arise? For all those passing away, for those being reborn in the formless realm, for them the feeling aggregate will cease, but for them the form aggregate does not arise. For those being reborn in the five-constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient realm,