English
for them unwholesome states do not cease, and unclassified states will not cease. (Kha) Or for whom unclassified states will not cease, for them do unwholesome states not cease? Yes. (Ṅa) The reverse situation. 150. Where wholesome states do not cease, there will unwholesome states not cease? ... (And so on) ... (Ca) The reverse situation for persons. 151. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome states do not cease, for them, there will unwholesome states not cease? At the moment of the arising of all thoughts, at the moment of the dissolution of thoughts dissociated from wholesome states, for them, there wholesome states do not cease, but for them, there unwholesome states will cease. At the moment of the arising of the highest path, for Arahants, at the moment of the arising of the thought immediately after which they will attain the highest path, for non-percipient beings, for them, there wholesome states do not cease, and unwholesome states will not cease. (Kha) Or for whom, where unwholesome states will not cease, for them, there do wholesome states not cease? At the moment of the dissolution of the highest path, for whom, at the thought immediately after which they will attain the highest path, at that thought... At their dissolution moment, there, unwholesome phenomena will not cease, and there, their wholesome phenomena do not cease. At the arising moment of the highest path for Arahants, immediately after which thought they will attain the highest path, at the arising moment of that thought for non-percipient beings, there, their unwholesome phenomena will not cease, and wholesome phenomena do not cease. (Q) For whom, where, wholesome phenomena do not cease, for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will not cease? For all, at the arising moment of thought, at the dissolution moment of thought dissociated from wholesome, for non-percipient beings, there, their wholesome phenomena do not cease, but for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will not cease. At the dissolution moment of the last thought, there, their wholesome phenomena do not cease, and indeterminate phenomena do not cease. (A) Or again, for whom, where, indeterminate phenomena will not cease, for them, there, wholesome phenomena do not cease? Yes. 152. (Q) For whom, where, unwholesome phenomena do not cease, for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will not cease? For all, at the arising moment of thought, at the dissolution moment of thought dissociated from unwholesome, for non-percipient beings, there, their unwholesome phenomena do not cease, but for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will not cease. At the dissolution moment of the last thought, there, their unwholesome phenomena do not cease, and indeterminate phenomena do not cease. (A) Or again, for whom, where, indeterminate phenomena will not cease, for them, there, unwholesome phenomena do not cease? Yes. (6) Section on Past and Future (Q) Direct Person 153. (Q) For whom wholesome phenomena ceased, for them unwholesome phenomena will cease? For Arahants endowed with the highest path, immediately after which thought they will attain the highest path, for them, wholesome phenomena ceased, but not For them, unwholesome states will cease. For others, wholesome states ceased, and unwholesome states will cease. (Kha) Or again, for whom unwholesome states will cease, for them, did wholesome states cease? Yes. (Ka) For whom wholesome states ceased, for them, will indeterminate states cease? At the moment of the cessation of the last thought, for them, wholesome states ceased, but for them, indeterminate states will not cease. For others, wholesome states ceased, and indeterminate states will cease. (Kha) Or again, for whom indeterminate states will cease, for them, did wholesome states cease? Yes. 154. (Ka) For whom unwholesome states ceased, for them, will indeterminate states cease? At the moment of the cessation of the last thought, for them, unwholesome states ceased, but for them, indeterminate states will not cease. For others, unwholesome states ceased, and indeterminate states will cease. (Kha) Or again, for whom indeterminate states will cease, for them, did unwholesome states cease? Yes. (Kha) Direct spatial context. 155. Where wholesome states ceased, there, will unwholesome states cease? ... (and so on) ... (Ga) Direct personal context. 156. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome states ceased, for them, there, will unwholesome states cease? For Arahants endowed with the highest path, for whom, immediately after that thought, they will attain the highest path, for them, there, wholesome states ceased, but for them, there, unwholesome states will not cease. For others, those of the four-constituent existence, and those of the five-constituent existence, for them, there, wholesome states ceased, and unwholesome states will cease. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where unwholesome states will cease, for them, there, did wholesome states cease? For those in the Pure Abodes, existing in the second thought. For them, there, unwholesome phenomena will not cease, and for them, there, wholesome phenomena did not cease. For others, those with four aggregates, those with five aggregates, for them, there, unwholesome phenomena will cease and wholesome phenomena did cease. (A) For whom, where, wholesome phenomena did cease, for him, there, indeterminate phenomena will cease? At the moment of the dissolution of the last thought, for them, there, wholesome phenomena did cease, but for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will not cease. For others, those with four aggregates, those with five aggregates, for them, there, wholesome phenomena did cease and indeterminate phenomena will cease. (B) Or again, for whom, where, indeterminate phenomena will cease, for him, there, wholesome phenomena did cease? For the Pure Abodes, at the second thought occurring, for the non-percipient beings, for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will cease, but for them, there, wholesome phenomena did not cease. For others, those with four aggregates, those with five aggregates, for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will cease and wholesome phenomena did cease. 157. (A) For whom, where, unwholesome phenomena did cease, for him, there, indeterminate phenomena will cease? At the moment of the dissolution of the last thought, for them, there, unwholesome phenomena did cease, but for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will not cease. For others, those with four aggregates, those with five aggregates, for them, there, unwholesome phenomena did cease and indeterminate phenomena will cease. (B) Or again, for whom, where, indeterminate phenomena will cease, for him, there, unwholesome phenomena did cease? For the Pure Abodes, at the second thought occurring, for the non-percipient beings, for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will cease, but for them, there, unwholesome phenomena did not cease. For others, those with four aggregates, those with five aggregates, for them, there, indeterminate phenomena will cease and unwholesome phenomena did cease. (Gha) The contrary person 158. (Ka) For whom wholesome phenomena did not cease, for him unwholesome phenomena will not cease? No. (Kha) Or for whom unwholesome phenomena will not cease, for him wholesome phenomena did not cease? They ceased. (Ka) For whom wholesome phenomena did not cease, for him indeterminate phenomena will not cease? No. (Kha) Or for whom indeterminate phenomena will not cease, for him wholesome phenomena did not cease? They ceased. 159. (Ka) For whom unwholesome phenomena did not cease, for him indeterminate phenomena will not cease? No. (Kha) Or for whom indeterminate phenomena will not cease, for him unwholesome phenomena did not cease? They ceased. (Ṅa) The contrary place 160. Where wholesome phenomena did not cease, there unwholesome phenomena will not cease? …(And so on)… (Ca) The contrary person-place 161. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome phenomena did not cease, for him, there unwholesome phenomena will not cease? For those in the Pure Abodes, when the second thought moment is occurring, for them, there wholesome phenomena did not cease, but for them, there unwholesome phenomena will not cease. For the non-percipient beings, for them, there wholesome phenomena did not cease, and unwholesome phenomena will not cease. (Kha) Or for whom, where unwholesome phenomena will not cease, for him, there wholesome phenomena did not cease? For Arahants endowed with the highest path, immediately after whose thought they will attain the highest path, for them, there unwholesome phenomena will not cease, but for them, there wholesome phenomena did not cease. For the non-percipient beings, for them, there unwholesome phenomena will not cease, and wholesome phenomena did not cease. (Ka) For whom, where wholesome phenomena did not cease, for him, there indeterminate phenomena will not cease will they cease? They will cease. (b) Or again, for whom, where indeterminate phenomena will not cease, for him, there, did wholesome phenomena not cease? They ceased. 162. (a) For whom, where unwholesome phenomena did not cease, for him, there, will indeterminate phenomena not cease? They will cease. (b) Or again, for whom, where indeterminate phenomena will not cease, for him, there, did unwholesome phenomena not cease? They ceased. Section on Cessation. 3. Section on Arising and Cessation (1) Section on the Present (a) Direct Person 163. (a) For whom wholesome phenomena arise, for him do unwholesome phenomena cease? No. (b) Or again, for whom unwholesome phenomena cease, for him do wholesome phenomena arise? No. (a) For whom wholesome phenomena arise, for him do indeterminate phenomena cease? No. (b) Or again, for whom indeterminate phenomena cease, for him do wholesome phenomena arise? No. 164. (a) For whom unwholesome phenomena arise, for him do indeterminate phenomena cease? No.