English
for them the feeling aggregate will arise and the form aggregate will arise. (B) Direct-place 63. (A) Where the form aggregate will arise, there the feeling aggregate will arise? In the non-percipient realm, there the form aggregate will arise, but there the feeling aggregate will not arise. In the five-constituent realms, there the form aggregate will arise and the feeling aggregate will arise. (B) Or again, where the feeling aggregate will arise, there the form aggregate will arise? In the formless realms, there the feeling aggregate will arise, but there the form aggregate will not arise. In the five-constituent realms, there the feeling aggregate will arise and the form aggregate will arise. (C) Direct-person-and-place 64. (A) For whom, where the form aggregate will arise... Will the aggregate of feeling arise for him there? For the non-percipient beings, the aggregate of form will arise for them there, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them there. For those in the five-constituent existences, both the aggregate of form will arise for them there, and the aggregate of feeling will arise. (Kha) Or moreover, for whom, where the aggregate of feeling will arise, will the aggregate of form arise for him there? For the formless beings, the aggregate of feeling will arise for them there, but the aggregate of form will not arise for them there. For those in the five-constituent existences, both the aggregate of feeling will arise for them there, and the aggregate of form will arise. (Gha) The opposing individual. 65. (Ka) For whom the aggregate of form will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for him? For those who, having been reborn in the formless realm, will attain final Nibbāna, the aggregate of form will not arise for them, but for them the aggregate of feeling will arise. For those in their last existence, both the aggregate of form will not arise for them, and the aggregate of feeling will not arise. (Kha) Or moreover, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of form not arise for him? Yes. (Ṅa) The opposing place. 66. (Ka) Where the aggregate of form will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise there? It will arise. (Kha) Or moreover, where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of form not arise there? It will arise. (Ca) The opposing individual and place. 67. (Ka) For whom, where the aggregate of form will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for him there? For the formless beings, the aggregate of form will not arise for them there, but for them there the aggregate of feeling will arise. For those in their last existence, both the aggregate of form will not arise for them there, and the aggregate of feeling will not arise. (Kha) Or moreover, for whom, where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of form not arise for him there? For the non-percipient beings, for them there, the feeling the mental aggregate will not arise, and for them there the form aggregate will not arise. For those in their last existence, for them there the feeling aggregate will not arise and the form aggregate will not arise. (4) Section on Present and Past (A) Direct Person 68. (A) For whom the form aggregate arises, for him did the feeling aggregate arise? Yes. (B) Or for whom the feeling aggregate arose, for him does the form aggregate arise? For all who are passing away, for those reborn in the immaterial realms, for them the feeling aggregate arose, but for them the form aggregate does not arise. For those reborn in the five-constituent realms, for those reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them the feeling aggregate arose and the form aggregate arises. 69. (A) For whom the feeling aggregate arises, for him did the perception aggregate arise? Yes. (B) Or for whom the perception aggregate arose, for him does the feeling aggregate arise? For all who are passing away, for those reborn in the non-percipient realm, for them the perception aggregate arose, but for them the feeling aggregate does not arise. For those reborn in the four-constituent realms, for those reborn in the five-constituent realms, for them the perception aggregate arose and the feeling aggregate arises. (B) Direct Location 70. (A) Where the form aggregate arises, there did the feeling aggregate arise? In the non-percipient realm, there the form aggregate arises, but there the feeling aggregate did not arise. In the five-constituent realms, there the form aggregate arises and the feeling aggregate arose. (B) Or where the feeling aggregate arose, there does the form aggregate arise? In the immaterial realms, there the feeling aggregate arose, but there the form aggregate does not arise. In the five-constituent realms, there the feeling aggregate arose and the form aggregate arises. 71. (A) Where the feeling aggregate arises, there did the perception aggregate arise? Yes. (B) Or where The aggregate of perception arose there, does the aggregate of feeling arise there? Yes. (C) Affirmative (persons and places) 72. (A) For whom, where, the aggregate of form arises, for him, there, did the aggregate of feeling arise? For those being reborn into the Pure Abodes, for those being reborn into the non-percipient realm, for them, there, the aggregate of form arises, but not for them, there, did the aggregate of feeling arise. For others, being reborn into the five-constituent existence, for them, there, the aggregate of form also arises, and the aggregate of feeling also arose. (B) Or for whom, where, the aggregate of feeling arose, for him, there, does the aggregate of form arise? For those passing away from the five-constituent existence, for those in the formless realms, for them, there, the aggregate of feeling arose, but not for them, there, does the aggregate of form arise. For those being reborn into the five-constituent existence, for them, there, the aggregate of feeling also arose, and the aggregate of form also arises. 73. (A) For whom, where, the aggregate of feeling arises, for him, there, did the aggregate of perception arise? For those being reborn into the Pure Abodes, for them, there, the aggregate of feeling arises, but not for them, there, did the aggregate of perception arise. For others, being reborn into the four-constituent or five-constituent existence, for them, there, the aggregate of feeling also arises, and the aggregate of perception also arose. (B) Or for whom, where, the aggregate of perception arose, for him, there, does the aggregate of feeling arise? For those passing away from the four-constituent or five-constituent existence, for them, there, the aggregate of perception arose, but not for them, there, does the aggregate of feeling arise. For those being reborn into the four-constituent or five-constituent existence, for them, there, the aggregate of perception also arose, and the aggregate of feeling also arises. (D) Negative (person) 74. (A) For whom the aggregate of form does not arise, for him did the aggregate of feeling not arise? It arose. (B) Or for whom the aggregate of feeling did not arise, for him does the aggregate of form not arise? There is none. 75. (Ka) For whom the aggregate of feeling does not arise, for him did the aggregate of perception not arise? It did arise. (Kha) Or again for whom the aggregate of perception did not arise, for him does the aggregate of feeling not arise? There is not. (Ṅa) The sphere of the contrary. 76. (Ka) Where the aggregate of form does not arise, there did the aggregate of feeling not arise? It did arise. (Kha) Or again where the aggregate of feeling did not arise, there does the aggregate of form not arise? It does arise. 77. (Ka) Where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, there did the aggregate of perception not arise? Yes. (Kha) Or again where the aggregate of perception did not arise, there does the aggregate of feeling not arise? Yes. (Ca) The spheres of contrary individuals. 78. (Ka) For whom where the aggregate of form does not arise, for him there did the aggregate of feeling not arise? For those passing away from the five-constituent existence, for the formless beings, for them there the aggregate of form does not arise, but for them there the aggregate of feeling did arise. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of form also does not arise, and the aggregate of feeling also did not arise. (Kha) Or again for whom where the aggregate of feeling did not arise, for him there does the aggregate of form not arise? For those arising in the Pure Abodes, for those arising in the non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling did not arise, but for them there the aggregate of form does arise. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling also did not arise, and the aggregate of form also does not arise. 79. (Ka) For whom where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, for him there did the aggregate of perception not arise? For those passing away from the four-constituent existence, from the five-constituent existence, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but for them there the aggregate of perception did arise. For those attaining final Nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for the non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling also does not arise, and the aggregate of perception also did not arise. did not arise. (Kha) Or, for whomsoever the perception aggregate did not arise there, did the feeling aggregate not arise there for them? For those reborn into the Pure Abodes, the perception aggregate did not arise there for them, but the feeling aggregate did arise there for them.