English
11. The Cluster of Clinging 69. The Dyad of Clinging 1. The Conditional Section 1. The Direct Order 1. The Analysis Section Root Condition 1. Clinging conditions clinging, by root condition – Wrong view clinging conditions sense-desire clinging, Sense-desire clinging conditions wrong view clinging, Rites-and-rituals clinging conditions sense-desire clinging, Sense-desire clinging conditions rites-and-rituals clinging, Self-doctrine clinging conditions sense-desire clinging, Sense-desire clinging conditions self-doctrine clinging. (1) Clinging conditions non-clinging, by root condition – Clinging conditions associated aggregates and mind-originated matter. (2) Clinging conditions clinging and non-clinging, by root condition – Wrong view clinging conditions sense-desire clinging and associated aggregates and mind-originated matter, Sense-desire clinging… (all the cycle should be done). (3) 2. Non-clinging conditions non-clinging, by root condition – One non-clinging aggregate conditions three aggregates and mind-originated matter… Two aggregates… At the moment of rebirth, one non-clinging aggregate conditions three aggregates and kamma-originated matter… Two aggregates… Aggregates condition the base, The base conditions aggregates, One great primary element… Great primary elements condition mind-originated matter, kamma-originated matter, derived matter. (1) Non-clinging conditions clinging, by root condition – Non-clinging aggregates condition clingings. (2) Non-clinging conditions clinging and non-clinging, by root condition – One non-clinging aggregate conditions three aggregates and clingings and mind-originated matter… Two aggregates condition two aggregates and clingings and mind-originated matter. (3) 3. Clinging and non-clinging condition clinging, by root condition – Wrong view clinging and associated And depending on those aggregates, sensual clinging. (All cycles should be made). (1) Depending on clinging and non-clinging phenomena, non-clinging phenomena arise due to a root condition – depending on one non-clinging aggregate and clinging, three aggregates and mind-originated matter, and two aggregates…etc… and depending on clinging and the great elements, mind-originated matter. (2) Depending on clinging and non-clinging phenomena, clinging and non-clinging phenomena arise due to a root condition – depending on one non-clinging aggregate and clinging to views, three aggregates and sensual clinging and mind-originated matter, and two aggregates…etc… (A cycle should be made). (3) Object Condition 4. Depending on clinging phenomena, clinging phenomena arise due to an object condition. (All nine questions should be made, matter should be omitted). 1. Conforming to Conditions 2. Enumeration Section 5. In root condition, nine, in object condition, nine, in dominance condition, nine (nine everywhere), in result, one…etc… in non-disappearance, nine. 2. Reverse of Conditions 1. Analysis Section Non-Root Condition 6. Depending on non-clinging phenomena, non-clinging phenomena arise due to a non-root condition – depending on one rootless non-clinging aggregate, three aggregates and mind-originated matter…etc… two aggregates…etc… at the moment of rootless rebirth-linking…etc… depending on aggregates, the base, depending on the base, aggregates, one great element…etc… depending on the great elements, mind-originated matter, kamma-originated matter, derived matter; external… food-originated… temperature-originated… of non-percipient beings…etc… depending on aggregates accompanied by doubt and accompanied by restlessness, doubt accompanied by restlessness, delusion accompanied by restlessness. (1) Non-Object Condition, etc. 7. Depending on clinging phenomena, non-clinging phenomena arise due to a non-object condition – depending on clinging, mind-originated matter. (1) Depending on non-clinging phenomena, non-clinging phenomena arise due to a non-object condition – depending on non-clinging aggregates… Dependent, mind-originated form; at the moment of rebirth, dependent on non-clinging aggregates, kamma-originated form, dependent on aggregates, the base, one great element...and so on... (up to the non-percipient beings). (1) Dependent on clinging and non-clinging phenomena, a non-clinging phenomenon arises, not by way of object condition – dependent on clinging and associated aggregates, mind-originated form, dependent on clinging and great elements, mind-originated form. (1) Not by way of dominance condition... not by way of contiguity condition...and so on... not by way of decisive support condition. Not by way of pre-existence condition 8. Dependent on a clinging phenomenon, a clinging phenomenon arises, not by way of pre-existence condition – in the formless realms, dependent on clinging to a self-view, clinging to sensual pleasures, dependent on clinging to sensual pleasures, clinging to a self-view. (1) Dependent on a clinging phenomenon, a non-clinging phenomenon arises, not by way of pre-existence condition – in the formless realms, dependent on clinging, associated aggregates, dependent on clinging, mind-originated form (abbreviated, all nine questions in the formless realms, two clingings). 2. Negative Condition 2. Enumeration Section Pure 9. Not by way of root, one, not by way of object, three, not by way of dominance, nine, not by way of contiguity, three...and so on... not by way of decisive support, three, not by way of pre-existence, nine, not by way of post-existence, nine, not by way of repetition, nine, not by way of kamma, three, not by way of result, nine, not by way of nutriment, one, not by way of faculty, one, not by way of jhāna, one, not by way of path, one, not by way of association, three, not by way of dissociation, nine, not by way of absence, three, not by way of disappearance, three. 3. Condition-Affirmative-Negative 10. By way of root condition, not by way of object, three, not by way of dominance, nine...and so on... not by way of decisive support, three, not by way of pre-existence, nine, not by way of post-existence, nine, not by way of repetition, nine, not by way of kamma, three, not by way of result, nine, not by way of association, three, not by way of dissociation, nine, not by way of absence, three, not by way of disappearance, three. 4. Condition-Negative-Affirmative 11. Not by way of root condition, by way of object, one (everywhere one), by way of path, one...and so on... by way of non-disappearance, one. 2. Co-existence Section (The Co-existence Section is similar to the Dependent Origination Section when distinguishing clinging to views It should be made: "conascent clinging to sensual pleasures." 3. Section on Conditions 1-4. Conditions in Direct Order, etc. Root Condition 12. A clinging phenomenon as condition, a clinging phenomenon arises by root condition. Clinging to views as condition, clinging to sensual pleasures... Three (similar to dependent origination). A non-clinging phenomenon as condition, a non-clinging phenomenon arises by root condition. One non-clinging aggregate as condition, three aggregates and mind-originated matter... Two aggregates... At the moment of rebirth-linking... Aggregates as condition, the base... (Up to the internal great elements) The base as condition, non-clinging aggregates. (1) A non-clinging phenomenon as condition, a clinging phenomenon arises by root condition. Non-clinging aggregates as condition, clingings. The base as condition, clingings. (2) A non-clinging phenomenon as condition, clinging and non-clinging phenomena arise by root condition. One non-clinging aggregate as condition, three aggregates (which are) clingings and mind-originated matter... Two aggregates... The base as condition, clingings. Great elements as condition, mind-originated matter. The base as condition, clingings and associated aggregates. (3) 13. A clinging and non-clinging phenomenon as condition, a clinging phenomenon arises by root condition. Clinging to views and associated aggregates as condition, clinging to sensual pleasures. Clinging to sensual pleasures and associated aggregates as condition, clinging to views. (A cycle should be made.) Clinging to views and the base as condition, clinging to sensual pleasures. (A cycle should be made.) (1) A clinging and non-clinging phenomenon as condition, a non-clinging phenomenon arises by root condition. One non-clinging aggregate and clinging as condition, three aggregates and mind-originated matter... Two aggregates and... (A cycle should be made.) Clinging and great elements as condition, mind-originated matter. Clinging and the base as condition, non-clinging aggregates. (2) A clinging and non-clinging phenomenon as condition, clinging and non-clinging and phenomena arise due to root condition – a non-clinging single aggregate and clinging-to-views, due to these, three aggregates, clinging-to-sensual-pleasures and mind-originated matter…etc… (cycle). Clinging-to-views and the base, due to these, clinging-to-sensual-pleasures and associated aggregates…etc… (cycle). (3) Due to object condition… (In the object condition, based on non-clinging, the five sense bases and the base should be done). In root, nine, in object, nine, in predominance, nine (everywhere nine), in result, one…etc… in non-disappearance, nine. Direct order. 14. A non-clinging phenomenon, due to it, a non-clinging phenomenon arises, not due to root condition – a rootless non-clinging single aggregate, due to it…etc… at the moment of rootless rebirth-linking…etc… (up to the non-percipient beings) the eye-base, due to it, eye-consciousness…etc… the body-base, due to it, body-consciousness, the base, due to it, rootless non-clinging aggregates, aggregates associated with doubt and restlessness, and the base, due to these, doubt-associated, restlessness-associated delusion. In non-root, one, in non-object, three, in non-predominance, nine, in non-contiguity, three,