English
for him, there did the eye-base arise? For those in the formless realm, for them, there the mind-base arose, but for them, there the eye-base did not arise. For those in the five-constituent existence, for them, there the mind-base also arose and the eye-base also arose. (Ka) For whom, where the eye-base arose, for him, there did the phenomena-base arise? Yes. (Kha) For whom Or again, where the mind-object base arose, did the eye base arise there for him? For the non-percipient beings, for the formless beings, for them, the mind-object base arose there, but for them, the eye base did not arise there. For the five-constituent beings, for them, the mind-object base arose there and the eye base arose there. 42. (Ka) For whom, where the nose base arose, did the form base arise there for him? Yes. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the form base arose, did the nose base arise there for him? For the beings in the form realm, for them, the form base arose there, but for them, the nose base did not arise there. For the beings in the sense-desire realm, for them, the form base arose there and the nose base arose there. (Ka) For whom, where the nose base arose, did the mind base arise there for him? Yes. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the mind base arose, did the nose base arise there for him? For the beings in the form realm, for the beings in the formless realm, for them, the mind base arose there, but for them, the nose base did not arise there. For the beings in the sense-desire realm, for them, the mind base arose there and the nose base arose there. (Ka) For whom, where the nose base arose, did the mind-object base arise there for him? Yes. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the mind-object base arose, did the nose base arise there for him? For the beings in the form realm, for the beings in the formless realm, for them, the mind-object base arose there, but for them, the nose base did not arise there. For the beings in the sense-desire realm, for them, the mind-object base arose there and the nose base arose there. 43. (Ka) For whom, where the form base arose, did the mind base arise there for him? For the non-percipient beings, for them, the form base arose there, but for them, the mind base did not arise there. And for them there, the mind-base arose. For them, the five-constituent beings, there, the form-base arose and the mind-base arose. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the mind-base arose, for them there, did the form-base arise? For the formless beings, for them there, the mind-base arose, but for them there, the form-base did not arise. For the five-constituent beings, for them there, the mind-base arose and the form-base arose. (Ka) For whom, where, the form-base arose, for them there, did the phenomena-base arise? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the phenomena-base arose, for them there, did the form-base arise? For the formless beings, for them there, the phenomena-base arose, but for them there, the form-base did not arise. For the five-constituent beings, the non-percipient beings, for them there, the phenomena-base arose and the form-base arose. (Rooted in the form-base). 44. (Ka) For whom, where, the mind-base arose, for them there, did the phenomena-base arise? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the phenomena-base arose, for them there, did the mind-base arise? For the non-percipient beings, for them there, the phenomena-base arose, but for them there, the mind-base did not arise. For the four-constituent beings, the five-constituent beings, for them there, the phenomena-base arose and the mind-base arose. (Rooted in the mind-base) (Gha) The opposing individual 45. (Ka) For whom the eye-base did not arise, for them did the ear-base not arise? There is none. (Kha) Or for whom the ear-base did not arise, for them did the eye-base not arise? There is none. (Abbreviated). 46. (Ka) For whom the mind-base did not arise, for them did the phenomena-base not arise? There is none. (Kha) Or for whom the phenomena-base did not arise, for them did the mind-base not arise? There is none. ... (And so on) ... (Ṅa) pac Contrary Occasion 47. Where the eye-base did not arise... (and so on)... (C) Contrary Persons and Occasions 48. (K) For whom, where the eye-base did not arise, for them, there the ear-base did not arise? Yes. (Kh) Or again, for whom, where the ear-base did not arise, for them, there the eye-base did not arise? Yes. (K) For whom, where the eye-base did not arise, for them, there the nose-base did not arise? Yes. (Kh) Or again, for whom, where the nose-base did not arise, for them, there the eye-base did not arise? For those in the Form Realm, for them, there the nose-base did not arise, but for them, there the eye-base did arise. For those in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for formless beings, for them, there both the nose-base did not arise and the eye-base did not arise. (K) For whom, where the eye-base did not arise, for them, there the form-base did not arise? For non-percipient beings, for them, there the eye-base did not arise, but for them, there the form-base did arise. For those in the Pure Abodes, for formless beings, for them, there both the eye-base did not arise and the form-base did not arise. (Kh) Or again, for whom, where the form-base did not arise, for them, there the eye-base did not arise? Yes. (K) For whom, where the eye-base did not arise, for them, there the mind-base did not arise? For formless beings, for them, there the eye-base did not arise, but for them, there the mind-base did arise. For those in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them, there both the eye-base did not arise and the mind-base did not arise. (Kh) Or again, for whom, where the mind-base did not arise, for them, there the eye-base did not arise? Yes. (K) For whom, where the eye-base did not arise, for them, there the phenomena-base did not arise? For non-percipient beings, for formless beings, for them, there the eye-base did not arise, but for them there the mind-object base did arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for them there the eye-base did not arise and the mind-object base did not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the mind-object base did not arise, for him there the eye-base did not arise? Yes. (Rooted in the Eye-base) 49. (Ka) For whom, where the nose-base did not arise, for him there the form-base did not arise? For those in the Form Realm, for them there the nose-base did not arise, but for them there the form-base did arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for the Formless, for them there the nose-base did not arise and the form-base did not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the form-base did not arise, for him there the nose-base did not arise? Yes. (Ka) For whom, where the nose-base did not arise, for him there the mind-base did not arise? For those in the Form Realm, for those in the Formless Realm, for them there the nose-base did not arise, but for them there the mind-base did arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for the non-percipient beings, for them there the nose-base did not arise and the mind-base did not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the mind-base did not arise, for him there the nose-base did not arise? Yes. (Ka) For whom, where the nose-base did not arise, for him there the mind-object base did not arise? For those in the Form Realm, for those in the Formless Realm, for them there the nose-base did not arise, but for them there the mind-object base did arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for them there the nose-base did not arise and the mind-object base did not arise. (Kha) Or again, for whom, where the mind-object base did not arise, for him there the nose-base did not arise? Yes. (Rooted in the Nose-base) 50. (Ka) For whom, where the form-base did not arise, for him there the mind-base did not arise? For the Formless, for them there the form- For those without form, for them there the form-base did not arise, but for them there the mind-base did not arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for them there the form-base did not arise and the mind-base did not arise. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the mind-base did not arise, for them there the form-base did not arise? For the non-percipient beings, for them there the mind-base did not arise, but for them there the form-base did not arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for them there the mind-base did not arise and the form-base did not arise. (Ka) For whom, or where, the form-base did not arise, for them there the phenomena-base did not arise? For those without form, for them there the form-base did not arise, but for them there the phenomena-base did not arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for them there the form-base did not arise and the phenomena-base did not arise. (Ka) Or for whom, or where, the phenomena-base did not arise, for them there the form-base did not arise? Yes. (Rooted in the form-base) 51. (Ka) For whom, or where, the mind-base did not arise, for them there the phenomena-base did not arise? For the non-percipient beings, for them there the mind-base did not arise, but for them there the phenomena-base did not arise. For those of the Pure Abodes, for them there the mind-base did not arise and the phenomena-base did not arise. (Kha) Or for whom, or where, the phenomena-base did not arise, for them there the mind-base did not arise? Yes. (Rooted in the mind-base) (3) The Future Section (Ka) Direct Person 52. (Ka) For whom the eye-base will arise, for them the ear-base will arise? Yes. (Kha) Or for whom the ear-base will arise, for them the eye-base will arise? Yes. (Ka) For whom the eye-base will arise, for them the nose-base will arise? Those who, having arisen in the Form Realm, will attain final Nibbāna, for them the eye-base will arise, but for them the nose-base will not arise. sense base will arise. For others, for them, the eye-base will arise and the nose-base will arise.