English
Consciousness, and matter, and Nibbāna – these phenomena do not follow after being conjoined with and arisen with consciousness. 1547. Which phenomena are internal? The eye-base… …the mind-base – these phenomena are internal. 1548. Which phenomena are external? The form-base… …the phenomena-base – these phenomena are external. 1549. Which phenomena are clung to? The eye-base… …and physical food – these phenomena are clung to. 1550. Which phenomena are not clung to? Wholesome states in the four planes, unwholesome states, resultant states in the four planes, functional indeterminate states in the three planes, and the four great elements, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are not clung to. 1551. Which phenomena are appropriated? Resultant states in the three planes, and that matter which is due to kamma – these phenomena are appropriated. 1552. Which phenomena are unappropriated? Wholesome states in the three planes, unwholesome states, functional indeterminate states in the three planes, and that matter which is not due to kamma, the four paths not included (in the planes), and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are unappropriated. The Clinging Section 1553. Which phenomena are clingings? The four clingings – clinging to sensual pleasures, clinging to views, clinging to rites and rituals, clinging to a doctrine of self. Clinging to sensual pleasures arises in the eight mind-moments accompanied by greed. Clinging to views, and clinging to rites and rituals, and clinging to a doctrine of self arise in the four mind-moments associated with wrong view – these phe Mother, clinging. 1554. Which states are not clinging? Excluding clinging, the remaining unwholesome states, wholesome states in the four planes, resultant states in the four planes, functional states in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these states are not clinging. 1555. Which states are clingable? Wholesome states in the three planes, unwholesome states, resultant states in the three planes, functional states in the three planes, and all form – these states are clingable. 1556. Which states are unclingable? The four paths not included in the planes, and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these states are unclingable. 1557. Which states are associated with clinging? The four thought-moments accompanied by greed associated with wrong view, the four thought-moments accompanied by greed dissociated from wrong view, excluding the greed arisen therein – these states are associated with clinging. 1558. Which states are dissociated from clinging? The greed arisen in the four thought-moments accompanied by greed dissociated from wrong view, the two thought-moments accompanied by displeasure, the thought-moment accompanied by doubt, the thought-moment accompanied by restlessness, wholesome states in the four planes, resultant states in the four planes, functional states in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these states are dissociated from clinging. 1559. Which states are clinging and also clingable? Those very clingings are clinging and also clingable. 1560. Which states are clingable and not clinging? Excluding clinging, the remaining unwholesome states, wholesome states in the three planes, resultant states in the three planes, functional states in the three planes, and all form – these states are clingable and not clinging. Unclingable states should not be said to be either clinging and also clingable, or clingable and not clinging. 1561. Which states are clinging and also associated with clinging? Where wrong view and greed arise together – these states are clinging and also associated with clinging. 1562. Which states are up Are they associated with clinging and not clinging? The eight mind-states accompanied by greed, excluding the clinging that arises therein – these phenomena are associated with clinging and are not clinging. Phenomena disassociated from clinging are not to be said to be both clinging and associated with clinging, nor to be associated with clinging and not clinging. 1563. Which phenomena are disassociated from clinging and are objects of clinging? The greed that arises in the four mind-states accompanied by greed, disassociated from wrong view; the two mind-states accompanied by displeasure; the mind-state accompanied by doubt; the mind-state accompanied by restlessness; wholesome states in the three planes; resultant states in the three planes; functional indeterminate states in the three planes; and all material form – these phenomena are disassociated from clinging and are objects of clinging. 1564. Which phenomena are disassociated from clinging and are not objects of clinging? The four paths not included (in the planes of existence), and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are disassociated from clinging and are not objects of clinging. Phenomena associated with clinging are not to be said to be disassociated from clinging and objects of clinging, nor to be disassociated from clinging and not objects of clinging. Cluster on Defilements 1565. Which phenomena are defilements? The ten bases of defilement – greed, hatred, delusion, conceit, wrong view, doubt, sloth, restlessness, shamelessness, lack of moral dread. Greed arises in the eight mind-states accompanied by greed. Hatred arises in the two mind-states accompanied by displeasure. Delusion arises in all unwholesome states. Conceit arises in the four mind-states accompanied by greed, disassociated from wrong view. Wrong view arises in the four mind-states associated with wrong view. Doubt arises in the mind-state accompanied by doubt. Sloth arises in unwholesome states with prompting. And restlessness, and shamelessness, and lack of moral dread arise in all unwholesome states – these phenomena are defilements. 1566. Which phenomena are not defilements? Excluding the defilements, the remaining unwholesome states; wholesome states in the four planes; resultant states in the four planes; Functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are not defilements. 1567. Which phenomena are defiling? Wholesome in the three planes, unwholesome, resultant in the three planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and all form – these phenomena are defiling. 1568. Which phenomena are undefiling? The four supramundane paths, and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are undefiling. 1569. Which phenomena are defiled? The twelve unwholesome consciousness-arisings – these phenomena are defiled. 1570. Which phenomena are undefiled? Wholesome in the four planes, resultant in the four planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are undefiled. 1571. Which phenomena are associated with defilements? The twelve unwholesome consciousness-arisings – these phenomena are associated with defilements. 1572. Which phenomena are dissociated from defilements? Wholesome in the four planes, resultant in the four planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are dissociated from defilements. 1573. Which phenomena are both defilements and defiling? Those very defilements are both defilements and defiling. 1574. Which phenomena are defiling but not defilements? The remaining unwholesome, excluding defilements, wholesome in the three planes, resultant in the three planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and all form – these phenomena are defiling but not defilements. Undefiling phenomena should not be said to be both defilements and defiling, nor defiling but not defilements. 1575. Which phenomena are both defilements and defiled? Those very defilements are both defilements and defiled. 1576. Which phenomena are defiled but not defilements? The remaining unwholesome, excluding defilements – these phenomena are defiled but not defilements. Undefiled phenomena should not be said to be both defilements and defiled, nor defiled but not defilements. 1577. K Which states are defilements and associated with defilements? Where two or three defilements arise together – these states are defilements and associated with defilements. 1578. Which states are associated with defilements but are not defilements? Excluding the defilements, the remaining unwholesome states – these states are associated with defilements but are not defilements. States dissociated from defilements should not be said to be defilements and associated with defilements, nor associated with defilements but not defilements. 1579. Which states are dissociated from defilements but conducive to defilement? Wholesome states in the three planes, resultant states in the three planes, functional indeterminate states in the three planes, and all material form – these states are dissociated from defilements but conducive to defilement. 1580. Which states are dissociated from defilements and not conducive to defilement? The four supramundane paths, and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these states are dissociated from defilements and not conducive to defilement. States associated with defilements should not be said to be dissociated from defilements and conducive to defilement, nor dissociated from defilements and not conducive to defilement. The Back Pair 1581. Which states are to be abandoned by insight? The four thought-moments associated with wrong view, the thought-moment accompanied by doubt – these states are to be abandoned by insight. The four thought-moments accompanied by greed, dissociated from wrong view, the two thought-moments accompanied by displeasure – these states are sometimes to be abandoned by insight, sometimes not to be abandoned by insight. 1582. Which states are not to be abandoned by insight? The thought-moment accompanied by restlessness, wholesome states in the four planes, resultant states in the four planes,