English
Commentary Section Extraction of Meanings from Triads 1384. Which phenomena are wholesome? Wholesome in the four planes – these phenomena are wholesome. 1385. Which phenomena are unwholesome? Twelve unwholesome mind-arisings – these phenomena are unwholesome. 1386. Which phenomena are indeterminate? Result in the four planes, functional indeterminate in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are indeterminate. 1387. Which phenomena are associated with pleasant feeling? From wholesome sense-sphere, four mind-arisings accompanied by joy; from unwholesome, four; from wholesome sense-sphere's result and functional, five; from wholesome, resultant, and functional form-sphere triple and quadruple jhānas; from wholesome and resultant supramundane triple and quadruple jhānas; excluding the pleasant feeling arisen therein – these phenomena are associated with pleasant feeling. 1388. Which phenomena are associated with painful feeling? Two mind-arisings accompanied by displeasure; body-consciousness accompanied by pain; excluding the painful feeling arisen therein – these phenomena are associated with painful feeling. 1389. Which phenomena are associated with neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling? From wholesome sense-sphere, four mind-arisings accompanied by equanimity; from unwholesome, six; from wholesome sense-sphere's result, ten; from unwholesome's result, six; from functional, six; from wholesome, resultant, and functional form-sphere fourth jhāna; from wholesome, resultant, and functional four immaterial-sphere states; from wholesome and resultant supramundane fourth jhāna; excluding the neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling arisen therein – these phenomena are associated with neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling. And the three feelings, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are not to be called associated with pleasant feeling, nor associated with painful feeling, nor associated with neither-painful-nor-pleasant feeling. 1390. Which phenomena are results? Result in the four planes – these phenomena are results. 1391. Which phe Which phenomena have result-producing nature? In the four planes, wholesome and unwholesome (actions) – these phenomena have result-producing nature. Which phenomena are neither result nor result-producing nature? In the three planes, functional (actions), and matter, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are neither result nor result-producing nature. Which phenomena are clung to and clingable? In the three planes, result (consciousness), and that matter produced by kamma – these phenomena are clung to and clingable. Which phenomena are not clung to but clingable? In the three planes, wholesome (actions), unwholesome (actions), in the three planes, functional (actions), and that matter not produced by kamma – these phenomena are not clung to but clingable. Which phenomena are not clung to and not clingable? The four paths not included (in the planes), and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are not clung to and not clingable. Which phenomena are defiled and defiling? The twelve unwholesome consciousness-arisings – these phenomena are defiled and defiling. Which phenomena are undefiled but defiling? In the three planes, wholesome (actions), in the three planes, result (consciousness), in the three planes, functional (actions), and all matter – these phenomena are undefiled but defiling. Which phenomena are undefiled and not defiling? The four paths not included (in the planes), and the four fruits of recluseship, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are undefiled and not defiling. Which phenomena are accompanied by initial application and sustained application? Wholesome sense-sphere (consciousness), unwholesome (consciousness), from the result of wholesome sense-sphere (consciousness), eleven consciousness-arisings, from the result of unwholesome (consciousness), two, from functional (consciousness), eleven, the first rūpa-sphere jhāna from wholesome, and from result, and from functional, the supramundane first jhāna from wholesome, and from result, excluding the initial and sustained application arisen therein – these phenomena are accompanied by initial application and sustained application. Which phenomena are without initial application, only with sustained application? In the fivefold rūpa-sphere system, the second jhāna from wholesome, and from result, and from functional, in the fivefold supramundane system, the second jhāna from wholesome... from wholesome and from result, excluding the investigation arisen therein, and initial application – these phenomena are merely without initial application, with investigation. 1401. Which phenomena are without initial application and without investigation? The two five-fold consciousnesses, the three-fold and four-fold rūpa-jhānas from wholesome, from result, and from functional, the four immaterial attainments from wholesome, from result, and from functional, the three-fold and four-fold supramundane jhānas from wholesome and from result, in the second jhāna according to the five-fold method, and the investigation arisen, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are without initial application and without investigation. The investigation co-arisen with initial application should not be called with initial application and with investigation, nor merely without initial application, with investigation, nor without initial application and without investigation. 1402. Which phenomena are accompanied by joy? From wholesome sense-sphere, the four consciousness-arisings accompanied by gladness, from unwholesome, the four, from the result of wholesome sense-sphere, the five, from functional, the five, the two-fold and three-fold rūpa-jhānas from wholesome, from result, and from functional, the two-fold and three-fold supramundane jhānas from wholesome and from result, excluding the joy arisen therein – these phenomena are accompanied by joy. 1403. Which phenomena are accompanied by happiness? From wholesome sense-sphere, the four consciousness-arisings accompanied by gladness, from unwholesome, the four, from the result of wholesome sense-sphere, the six, from functional, the five, the three-fold and four-fold rūpa-jhānas from wholesome, from result, and from functional, the three-fold and four-fold supramundane jhānas from wholesome and from result, excluding the happiness arisen therein – these phenomena are accompanied by happiness. 1404. Which phenomena are accompanied by equanimity? From wholesome sense-sphere, the four consciousness-arisings accompanied by equanimity, from unwholesome, the six, from the result of wholesome sense-sphere, the ten, from the result of unwholesome, the six, from functional, the six, the fourth rūpa-jhāna from wholesome, from result, and from functional, the four immaterial attainments from wholesome, from result, and from functional, the fourth supramundane jhāna from wholesome and from result, excluding the equanimity arisen therein – these phenomena are accompanied by equanimity. Associated with *khā*. Joy is not associated with joy, associated with happiness, not associated with equanimity. Happiness is not associated with happiness, it may be associated with joy, not associated with equanimity, it may not be said to be associated with joy. Two mind-arisings associated with displeasure, body-consciousness associated with pain, and the feeling of equanimity, and form and Nibbāna – these phenomena are not to be called associated with joy, nor associated with happiness, nor associated with equanimity. 1405. Which phenomena are to be abandoned by insight? Four mind-arisings conjoined with wrong view, a mind-arising associated with doubt – these phenomena are to be abandoned by insight. 1406. Which phenomena are to be abandoned by development? A mind-arising associated with restlessness – these phenomena are to be abandoned by development. Four mind-arisings associated with greed, disjoined from wrong view, two mind-arisings associated with displeasure – these phenomena may be abandoned by insight, may be abandoned by development. 1407. Which phenomena are to be abandoned neither by insight nor by development? Wholesome in the four planes, result in the four planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and form, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are to be abandoned neither by insight nor by development. 1408. Which phenomena have causes to be abandoned by insight? Four mind-arisings conjoined with wrong view, a mind-arising associated with doubt, excluding the delusion arisen therein – these phenomena have causes to be abandoned by insight. 1409. Which phenomena have causes to be abandoned by development? A mind-arising associated with restlessness, excluding the delusion arisen therein – these phenomena have causes to be abandoned by development. Four mind-arisings associated with greed, disjoined from wrong view, two mind-arisings associated with displeasure – these phenomena may have causes to be abandoned by insight, may have causes to be abandoned by development. 1410. Which phenomena have causes to be abandoned neither by insight nor by development? Delusion associated with doubt, delusion associated with restlessness, wholesome in the four planes, c Results in the four planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and matter, and Nibbāna – these phenomena are to be abandoned neither by insight nor by development. 1411. Which phenomena lead to accumulation? Wholesome and unwholesome in the three planes – these phenomena lead to accumulation. 1412. Which phenomena lead to non-accumulation? The four paths not included – these phenomena lead to non-accumulation. 1413. Which phenomena lead neither to accumulation nor non-accumulation? Results in the four planes, functional-indeterminate in the three planes, and matter, and Nibbāna – these phenomena lead neither to accumulation nor non-accumulation. 1414.