English
and by settlement by incorrigibility. By three methods they are not settled – by majority vote, and by acknowledgement, and by covering with grass. And the offense dispute and the business dispute, by how many methods are they settled? By how many methods are they not settled? The offense dispute and the business dispute are settled by three methods – by settlement in presence, and by acknowledgement, and by covering with grass. By four methods they are not settled – by majority vote, and by settlement by mindfulness, and by settlement by past sanity, and by settlement by incorrigibility. And the dispute over Dhamma-Vinaya, and the accusation dispute, and the offense dispute, by how many methods are they settled? By how many methods are they not settled? The dispute over Dhamma-Vinaya, and the accusation dispute, and the offense dispute are settled by seven methods – by settlement in presence, and by majority vote, and by settlement by mindfulness, and by settlement by past sanity, and by acknowledgement, and by settlement by incorrigibility, and by covering with grass. And the dispute over Dhamma-Vinaya, and the accusation dispute, and the business dispute, by how many methods are they settled? By how many methods are they not settled? The dispute over Dhamma-Vinaya, and the accusation dispute, and the business dispute are settled by five methods – by settlement in presence, and by majority vote, and by settlement by mindfulness, and by settlement by past sanity, and by settlement by incorrigibility. By two methods they are not settled – by acknowledgement, and by covering with grass. And the accusation dispute, and the offense dispute, and the business dispute, by how many methods are they settled? By how many methods are they not settled? The accusation dispute, and the offense dispute, and the business dispute are settled by six methods – by settlement in presence, and by settlement by mindfulness, and by settlement by past sanity, and by acknowledgement. and by the admission of guilt, and by the procedure for the declaration of depravity, and by the covering over with grass. They are not settled by one settlement – by the decision by majority. And disputes concerning doctrine, and disputes concerning accusations, and disputes concerning offenses, and disputes concerning duties, by how many settlements are they settled? By how many settlements are they not settled? Disputes concerning doctrine, and disputes concerning accusations, and disputes concerning offenses, and disputes concerning duties, are settled by seven settlements – by settlement in the presence, and by decision by majority, and by settlement by recollection, and by settlement for the insane, and by admission of guilt, and by the procedure for the declaration of depravity, and by the covering over with grass. The section on 'Are settled, are not settled', the eighteenth, is finished. 19. Section on Settlements and Disputes 309. Are settlements settled by settlements? Are settlements settled by disputes? Are disputes settled by settlements? Are disputes settled by disputes? It may be that settlements are settled by settlements, it may be that settlements are not settled by settlements. It may be that settlements are settled by disputes, it may be that settlements are not settled by disputes. It may be that disputes are settled by settlements, it may be that disputes are not settled by settlements. It may be that disputes are settled by disputes, it may be that disputes are not settled by disputes. 310. How may settlements be settled by settlements, how may settlements not be settled by settlements? The decision by majority is settled by settlement in the presence; it is not settled by settlement by recollection, it is not settled by settlement for the insane, it is not settled by admission of guilt, it is not settled by the procedure for the declaration of depravity, it is not settled by the covering over with grass. Settlement by recollection is settled by settlement in the presence; it is not settled by settlement for the insane, it is not settled by admission of guilt, it is not settled by the procedure for the declaration of depravity, it is not settled by the covering over with grass, it is not settled by the decision by majority. Settlement for the insane is settled by settlement in the presence; it is not settled by admission of guilt, it is not settled by the procedure for the declaration of depravity, it is not settled by the covering over with grass, it is not settled by the decision by majority, it is not settled by settlement by recollection. is settled. Settlement by admission is settled by settlement in the presence; is not settled by settlement for the more blameworthy, is not settled by settlement by covering with grass, is not settled by settlement by majority, is not settled by settlement by appeal to memory, is not settled by settlement for the unbewildered. Settlement for the more blameworthy is settled by settlement in the presence; is not settled by settlement by covering with grass, is not settled by settlement by majority, is not settled by settlement by appeal to memory, is not settled by settlement for the unbewildered, is not settled by settlement by admission. Settlement by covering with grass is settled by settlement in the presence; is not settled by settlement by majority, is not settled by settlement by appeal to memory, is not settled by settlement for the unbewildered, is not settled by settlement by admission, is not settled by settlement for the more blameworthy. Thus, settlements might be settled by settlements. Thus, settlements might not be settled by settlements. 311. How might settlements be settled by cases, how might settlements not be settled by cases? Settlement in the presence is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. Settlement by majority is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. Settlement by appeal to memory is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. Settlement for the unbewildered is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. Settlement by admission is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. Settlement for the more blameworthy is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. Settlement by covering with grass is not settled by a dispute case, is not settled by an accusation case, is not settled by an offense case; is settled by a duty case. by an offense-dispute, it is not settled; by a duty-dispute, it is settled. Thus, the settlements might settle the disputes. Thus, the settlements might not settle the disputes. 312. How might disputes be settled by settlements, how might disputes not be settled by settlements? A dispute of contention is settled by settlement in the presence and by decision by majority; by settlement by recollection, and by settlement for an unbewildered person, and by settlement by acknowledgement, and by settlement for a worse deed, and by settlement by covering with grass, it is not settled. A dispute of accusation is settled by settlement in the presence, and by settlement by recollection, and by settlement for an unbewildered person, and by settlement for a worse deed; by decision by majority, and by settlement by acknowledgement, and by settlement by covering with grass, it is not settled. A dispute of offense is settled by settlement in the presence, and by settlement by acknowledgement, and by settlement by covering with grass; by decision by majority, and by settlement by recollection, and by settlement for an unbewildered person, and by settlement for a worse deed, it is not settled. A dispute of duty is settled by settlement in the presence; by decision by majority, and by settlement by recollection, and by settlement for an unbewildered person, and by settlement by acknowledgement, and by settlement for a worse deed, and by settlement by covering with grass, it is not settled. Thus, disputes might be settled by settlements. Thus, disputes might not be settled by settlements. 313. How might disputes be settled by disputes? How might disputes not be settled by disputes? A dispute of contention is not settled by a dispute of contention, is not settled by a dispute of accusation, is not settled by a dispute of offense; by a dispute of duty, it is settled. A dispute of accusation is not settled by a dispute of contention, is not settled by a dispute of accusation, is not settled by a dispute of offense; by a dispute of duty, it is settled. A dispute of offense is not settled by a dispute of contention, is not settled by a dispute of accusation, is not settled by a dispute of offense; by a dispute of duty, it is settled. A dispute of duty is not settled by a dispute of contention, is not settled by a dispute of accusation, by an offense-dispute By a trifle it is not settled; by a business-case it is settled. Thus it may be that cases are settled by cases. Thus it may be that cases are not settled by cases. Even the six methods of settlement and the four cases are settled by the Rule of Presence; the Rule of Presence is not settled by anything. The Chapter on Settlements and Cases is finished, the nineteenth. 20. The Chapter on Origination 314. The Dispute Case, of the four cases, which case does it give rise to? The Dispute Case, of the four cases, does not give rise to any case; but rather, due to the Dispute Case, the four cases arise. How is that? Here monks dispute –